Are the Environmental Challenges and Ethical Dilemmas Fisher & Paykel Currently Face Outsourcing Manufacturing to a Developing Country Overall Beneficial to Australia?

In: Business and Management

Submitted By meganelizabeth
Words 3913
Pages 16
Research Essay 3000 words
Globalisation presents significant opportunities and challenges for business around the world. Are the environmental challenges and ethical dilemmas Fisher & Paykel currently face outsourcing manufacturing to a developing country beneficial to Australia?
Globalisation can be described as the intertwining processes of the world. It is not only an economic process, which involves rising communication and integration of all countries’ economies through the growth in international trade and investment, but also the rapid cultural, social, technological and industrial exchange between nations (IYP, 2002, p. 11). Globalisation presents significant opportunities, as well as many challenges, for business around the globe. Many companies are currently making the decision to move production offshore to lower expenditure and increase profits. However, there are numerous environmental challenges, as well as ethical dilemmas involved with outsourcing. Throughout this essay I will show how globalisation is connected with the present issue of New Zealand’s ‘Fisher & Paykel’ (F&P) Brisbane plant outsourcing manufacturing of their whitegoods to Thailand. Shown by exploring the reasons and challenges involved both in the business environment and ethical arena. Such ethical issues under scrutiny at present are the loss of Australian jobs and the replacement of low wage employment offshore. After the analysis of various sources of information, it will be clear that the move by Fisher & Paykel, to commence production offshore, is in fact beneficial to the Australian economy.
Globalisation is not a new process, but rather the result of human modernisation and advancement, and, industrial and technological development. Although the term ‘globalisation’ is widely used there is no clear or universally accepted definition. For the purposes of this essay, in the…...

Similar Documents


...Fisher & Paykel 1934 Company founded in Auckland by Woolf Fisher and Maurice Paykel to import Crosley refrigerators, Maytag washing machines and Pilot mantle radios. 1938 Sales agreement signed with Kelvinator Corporation, Detroit. 1939 Manufacture of refrigerators and wringer washing machines. 1953 Installation of first washing machine conveyer line. 1955 First stage of Mt Wellington plant starts production of refrigeration and laundry products. 1956 Manufacture of rotary clothes dryers designed and patented by company. Formed association with HE Shacklock, Dunedin. 1957 Allied Industries Ltd established to manufacture Murphy radios and radiograms and later (1960) television receivers. This was the forerunner of Fisher & Paykel Electronics. 1958 Fisher & Paykel open a London office. 1965 Agreement signed with Matsushita Electric for sole distributorship in New Zealand. 1966 Head Office moved to Mt Wellington. Champion Spark Plug New Zealand established. Allied Industries began manufacturing Waikato electric fence controllers. 1969 Allied Industries began manufacturing television tubes. 1970 First respiratory humidifier sold. 1971 Agreement with Matsushita Electric for marketing and eventual manufacture of National Panasonic products. Manufacture of respiratory humidifier(the beginnings of Healthcare). 1972 East Tamaki refrigerator manufacturing plant opens. 1974 One millionth refrigerator and one millionth laundry unit produced. Allied......

Words: 2234 - Pages: 9

India Outsourcing and the Ethical Dilemma

...Is Offshore Outsourcing of Medical Business Practices Ethical? Abstract The healthcare industry is one of the largest in the United States. The United States spends an estimated $2 trillion annually on health care expenses, more than any other industrialized country (Johnson, 2010). The growth of this industry is expected to continue well into the future. However, today more than ever, healthcare providers are faced with many financial pressures. Offshore outsourcing offers companies substantial savings on costs which improves profitability. Managed care organizations and healthcare providers realize how outsourcing business processes to experts allows them to focus on their core business without worrying about back-office functions (Namasivayan & Bell, 2006). Despite the cost savings, it is important not to overlook some of the issues that may be associated with outsourcing. Is Offshore Outsourcing of Medical Business Practices Ethical? The healthcare industry is one of the largest in the United States. The United States spends an estimated $2 trillion annually on health care expenses, more than any other industrialized country (Johnson, 2010). The growth of this industry is expected to continue well into the future. As the baby boomer population gets older and medical treatments become more and more advanced, those needing medical care will increase exponentially giving rise to an already growing field. Yet,......

Words: 3299 - Pages: 14

Ethical Impact of Outsourcing

...Ethical Impact of Outsourcing Will Pearsall June 17, 2010 MGT/216 Vicki Dixon Ethical Impact of Outsourcing Over the last few years it seems almost impossible to read a newspaper, turn on the TV or call a customer service representative without noticing one of the most growing trends in business, the outsourcing of jobs overseas. Due to its political and economical ramifications we witness numerous debates on the topic. Although it makes economical sense for companies to contract the cheapest labor, the movement of jobs to other countries presents an ethical dilemma. In this paper I will discuss the impact of outsourcing across cultures as well as the consequences faced by companies that decide to employ it. According to Credo reference (2004), “outsourcing is the term used to describe the practice of subcontracting certain services to an organization or company outside of the parent organization or company.” Subcontracting of specialized jobs has been a common theme in the US and has positively impacted our economy. It allows companies that are not adequately skilled in a specific task to hire a company that is. It is common in industries like health care, manufacturing, and information technology. However, with the explosion of globalization over the last decade, we have witness this trend shift to negatively affect our domestic workforce. With growing competition and increased pressure from stakeholders and shareholders to increase profit margins, companies are......

Words: 673 - Pages: 3

Ethical Dilemmas and Challenges in Counseling

...Some of the challenges about ethics and law related to my future counseling practice include imposing my own values, beliefs and ideals on clients, maintaining the competence and skills needed to effectively abide by said ethics and laws and deciphering how to take action when laws and ethics collide. Ethics are the philosophical underpinnings of human conduct, and it is important for counselors to uphold all aspects of ethics in order to provide the highest level of care and avoid charges of unethical conduct (Bradley & Hendricks, 2008). Two forms of ethics that exist are principle ethics and virtue ethics. Principle ethics embody moral principles that are widely agreed upon beliefs that make up helping professions. The six main moral principles include autonomy, nonmaleficence, beneficence, justice, fidelity and veracity. The second form of ethics is virtue ethics. Virtue ethics revolve around personal characteristics and virtues and entail integrity, discernment, acceptance of emotion, self-awareness and interdependence with the community (Remley & Herlihy, 2014). According to Jennings, et al. (2005), one key to avoiding ethical dilemmas is by avoiding personal biases and views in client sessions. According the ACA Code of Ethics (2005), any personal views that are not aligned with counseling goals must be avoided, and counselors need to remain aware of these views and respect all forms of diversity when it relates to clients, trainees and research participants. Because...

Words: 1359 - Pages: 6

Global Trends: Manufacturing and Outsourcing

...Group Written Assignment 1 Global Trends: Manufacturing and Outsourcing Over the past decades various businesses across the globe have made shifts in the way manufacturing is handled in their companies. Some have outsourced the full scope of their manufacturing. While others have done partial outsourcing, where partial assembly is returned to the US industry. When manufacturing is outsourced, whether for goods or services, many companies downsize their work force. This creates a loss of jobs for the American industries while increasing jobs in places such as China, India and Indonesia, just to mention a few. Outsourcing, undoubtedly has its comparative advantages as far as having lower wages but it also has risks such as rising costs and trade barriers. It is some of these challenges that is believed to have created a slow re-routing of manufacturing to return to the US Industry. The global trend in manufacturing and outsourcing is that many countries rely heavily on China and other developing nations for manufacturing. For this reason many countries outsource their manufacturing to China. In the article, “The end of cheap China,” the writer reminds us that, “China is the world’s largest manufacturing power and they account for a fifth of global manufacturing.” The primary reason for this trend is due to the cheap labor. It should be noted that global manufacturing is also advantageous to China and other developing nations, since it facilitates economic......

Words: 1083 - Pages: 5

Procurement in Oil and Gas Industry in Developing Countries Nigeria Agip

...Procurement in Oil and Gas Industry in Developing Countries A Case of AGIP Nigeria Name Course Professor Date Abstract This is a thesis about procurement process in the oil and gas industry in Nigeria with specific stress on AGIP Nigerian AGIP Energy and Natural Resource.” The report starts with an introduction to the country Nigeria itself. It develops with the research on the oil and gas sector in the country and then focuses on the AGIP and its operations. Thus the first section comprises the Introduction, the background of the problem the research objectives, literature review regarding the procurement process and the company AGIP. The second section is about the research methodology, the data analysis and presentation of results leading to limitations and recommendations and a conclusion. A qualitative research design has been used to do the research. These research methods have been used by every researcher in a way or other and quality data has been accumulated to help these researchers to prove their viewpoint either statistically (quantitative) or by subjective analysis of earlier researches or direct observations of the subjects (qualitatively). The data sources used for the literature review for this study are primarily the secondary sources particularly from books, journals, articles published in various scientific periodicals and / or newspapers along with the information gathered from the internet itself using its websites.  The study manoeuvres at two......

Words: 12215 - Pages: 49

Fisher and Paykel Swot

...CASE STUDY AUSTRALIAN WINE INDUSTRY 1. Identify Company’s (Witchmount Estate) objectives. [pic] Corporate - To be one of the top 3 wine estates in Victoria within 5 years. - Produce well known varieties of wine, such as, Chardonay, Sauvignon blanc, Shiraz & Cabernet sauvignon. - Develop new varieties like Pinot Gris. - Expansion & development of the winery, by building new modern wine manufacturing & tasting facilities. Build new restaurant. Build Conference and accommodation facilities. - A more recognisable logo “W”. - Wine produced to be divided into separate lines, and to sell in different price categories to cater for a wider market, pricing to be below & above $20 price point. Marketing - On-site and in the local community - Invite well known Australian performers to perform concerts within the winery. Advertising - Local media (newspapers & radio) within 20km radius. - Industry magazines - Conferences - Festivals - In other wine regions of Victoria - The closet winery to Melbourne CBD • Develop relationships with City hotel concierges • Offer their patrons Wine tasting package, Tour to the winery for a meal and wine tasting, with buses arranged by Witchmount to transport patrons. 2. Define the problem ...

Words: 2449 - Pages: 10

Ethical Dilemma

...Job 9 Enter Organizational Behavior 10 Complementing Intuition with Systematic Study 11 Disciplines That Contribute to the OB Field 13 Psychology 14 • Social Psychology 14 • Sociology 14 • Anthropology 14 There Are Few Absolutes in OB 14 Challenges and Opportunities for OB 15 Responding to Economic Pressures 15 • Responding to Globalization 16 • Managing Workforce Diversity 18 • Improving Customer Service 18 • Improving People Skills 19 • Stimulating Innovation and Change 20 • Coping with “Temporariness” 20 • Working in Networked Organizations 20 • Helping Employees Balance Work–Life Conflicts 21 • Creating a Positive Work Environment 22 • Improving Ethical Behavior 22 Coming Attractions: Developing an OB Model 23 An Overview 23 • Inputs 24 • Processes 25 • Outcomes 25 Summary and Implications for Managers 30 S A L Self-Assessment Library How Much Do I Know About Organizational Behavior? 4 Myth or Science? “Most Acts of Workplace Bullying Are Men Attacking Women” 12 An Ethical Choice Can You Learn from Failure? 24 glOBalization! Does National Culture Affect Organizational Practices? 30 Point/Counterpoint Lost in Translation? 31 Questions for Review 32 Experiential Exercise Workforce Diversity 32 Ethical Dilemma Jekyll and Hyde 33 Case Incident 1 “Lessons for ‘Undercover’ Bosses” 34 Case Incident 2 Era of the Disposable Worker? 35 vii viii CONTENTS 2 2 The Individual Diversity in Organizations 39 Diversity......

Words: 393199 - Pages: 1573

Ethical Dilemmas of Outsourcing

...University Abstract Outsourcing is the catchphrase shaking up the worldwide financial environment. Offshoring or outsourcing has changed the way many businesses and individual coexist today. Each person today, respects many aspects of offshoring/outsourcing and we have learned that more organizations are using different assets from offshoring to pick up a business advantage. With the changing worldwide economy, and the inordinate expenses connected with keeping an employees at a staffed capacity, a large number of today's organizations and partnerships are outsourcing the generation of merchandise and administrations to outside firms with an end goal to cut expenses. While numerous experts contend that this can decimate nearby economies by cutting employments at home. There are numerous disservices to offshoring which affects our American workers and families and the practice of offshoring has taken a turn in the direction of an unethical practice. For laborers in the US, various occupations are lost permently, numerous workers need to increase new abilities, due to dimished wages because of the intensity of abroad laborers. Fundamentally, American laborers are presently compelled to contend on a worldwide level, as are organizations in this global commerce. Offshoring: The Future of American Workers Offshoring and outsourcing are words that many use interchangeably. Nevertheless, there are keen variations between the two. Outsourcing and offshoring are a......

Words: 1380 - Pages: 6

Outsourcing Jobs to Low Wage Countries

...Outsourcing Jobs to Low Wage Countries Research and Key Issues Business outsourcing, a practice that was previously shrouded in controversy has become commonplace, not only among technology firms but also the IT departments of established companies in various industries. The bulk of overseas outsourcing, a practice that involves companies in economically developed nations shipping jobs to businesses in developing countries, has expanded after the practice became fashionable during the period of economic boom in the mid 1990’s. During this time, the outlook of the practice remained relatively unchanged, though this seems to be changing. For instance, firms that deal with outsourcing are starting to consolidate, resulting in larger providers who offer a wider range of services. Niche providers are also coming forth. Additionally, developing nations such as China and India are in direct competition with one another (Sornarajah 277). India has been the traditional outsourcing –services leader. Initially, outsourcing was the preserve of the larger companies, but now even the smaller and mid-size businesses are beginning to outsource jobs. Additionally, the previous practice was to outsource large projects, for instance call-center operations and basic application development. Today, as outsourcing is becoming more commonplace, companies are beginning to outsource smaller projects such as research and development (R&D) and scientific projects to external providers. Many......

Words: 2993 - Pages: 12

Fisher & Paykel

...Organization Background Fisher & Paykel Ltd. (F&P) Located in Auckland, New Zealand was the largest home appliance manufacturer of major appliances in the country with eight operating divisions. It’s major appliance sales amount to $135,000,000 with total sales of $270,000,000 annually including annual export sales and royalty income of $36,000,000. The Laundry Division of F&P has spent two years developing a new washing machine with a projected annual production level of 75,000 to 100,000 and 50,000 for the first full year of production to start the beginning of next April. Defining the issue The key concerns are: 1. Getting the best quality, quantity, price and service for the required parts while adhering to the New Zealand’s importing licensing policies 2. Coming up with clear parts sourcing decisions and direction quickly Due to the automated production process planned for the new machines, new plastic cable ties with new specifications will have to be produced as none of the existing ties suppliers actually have them in stock. Each machine will require 45 plastic clips with 6 different part numbers for a total of 4,500,000 annually given the projected production of 100,000 machines a year. With the lead times involved before the first production run in April, F& P must resolve the 2 key concerns above as soon as possible. Analyzing the Case Data There are 4 possible plastic clip suppliers: Olson Plastics: * Quoted 4 out of the 6......

Words: 978 - Pages: 4

. What Are the Challenges Posed by Sustainable Development for Developing Countries?

...Some of the critical issues for sustainable development in developing countries and the policies to deal with them include:- • Jobs: Economic recession has caused a lot of unemployment in the developing nations. Labor markets are vital not only for the production and generation of wealth. "Green jobs" are positions in agriculture, industry, services and administration that contribute to preserving or restoring the quality of the environment. In order to create more jobs, sustainable development strategies need a strong employment component which aims at raising the productivity of the poorest workers, and at ensuring that they get to keep most of their increased earning power by progressively strengthening labor market institutions. Increase in trade will also lead to creation of more jobs. • Energy: Energy is central to nearly every major challenge and opportunity the world faces today. Be it for jobs, security, climate change, food production or increasing incomes, access to energy for all is essential. Sustainable energy is needed for strengthening economies, protecting ecosystems and achieving equity. Government should look for the financing of new energy sources. Government need to look for more foreign investment and encourage domestic investment also. • Food: Due to rapid increase in world population, there is scarcity of food everywhere. The food and agriculture sector offers key solutions for development, and is central for hunger and poverty eradication.......

Words: 576 - Pages: 3

Nike Ethical Dilemmas

...NIKE - ETHICAL ISSUES AND DILEMMAS INTRODUCTION Nike has been dodging accusations of employing people in the developing and under-developed economies, at low wages and poor working conditions for a considerable period of time. Having tried course correction and public relations as a measure to salvage the bad image generated by the sweatshops that Nike is accused of running, Nike has undertaken massive efforts to overcome these hurdles. Herein we will analyze Nike's international business operations with a critical eye over the ethical issues and dilemmas that this organization has faced while manufacturing its goods in foreign lands. PROBLEM AREAS There are a number of areas that are seen as weak points or links in this Nike case. We shall first highlight the problem areas and then dive into the ethical theories that are supposed to govern them. According to the Wikipedia dictionary, ethics is defined as a general term for the science of morality. While this branch of study can be further sub-divided into various categories, we have to remember that what is appropriate in a given situation may not be so among different circumstances and the decision of right or wrong is relative to its surroundings. Elaborated here are the issues and problems that stand out due to their ethical nature as issues or dilemmas faced by Nike and its operations towards its employees and customers as mentioned in the case study: Poor Working Conditions - In Nike factories, the laborers were......

Words: 2054 - Pages: 9


...Fisher & Paykel Appliances Holdings Ltd, it committed to gathering actionable customer data to drive product innovation and improvement. The innovation represented the competitive advantages for this company. It also focused on building a strong appealing global brand and aware that high quality product and service are crucial to both the company’s image and profitability. Company is trying to leverage their competitive advantage to provide the industry with sum systems, enabling technologies application integration and manufacturing equipment. The strenth Fisher & Paykel Australia, strategic partnership of Fisher & Paykel Appliances with Haier offers opportunities for the appliance manufacturers with access to new products and lucrative, global markets. The partnership with Haier provides Fisher & Paykel Appliances with rapid access to products and markets. Haier will take the Fisher & Paykel Appliances brand to market in their home market of China, while Fisher & Paykel Appliances will distribute the Haier brand in New Zealand and Australia. Haier have been working with Fisher & Paykel Appliances since 2004. Fisher & Paykel Appliances Holdings Ltd has transferred most of its production to low-cost countries, and plans to transfer nearly all production to these countries. The company has its own sales companies in New Zealand, Australia, Singapore, the United Kingdom and the United States. They are supported by distributors in over 40 countries, particularly in......

Words: 615 - Pages: 3

Fisher and Paykel

...Fisher & Paykel Appliances Holdings Limited FPA Stock Exchange Release ASX/NZX 17 April 2008 Fisher & Paykel Appliances Announces Global Manufacturing Strategy Fisher & Paykel Appliances today unveiled its new global manufacturing strategy. As announced earlier today, the Company has acquired land and buildings and a refrigeration manufacturing plant located in Reynosa, Mexico. The new global manufacturing strategy involves shifting three of the Company’s manufacturing facilities to a combination of existing sites in Thailand and Italy and its recently purchased facility in Mexico. Inclusive of the Reynosa acquisition and the new North American DishDrawer line announced late last year, the financial benefits arising from the new strategy are expected to be in the vicinity of $50 million per annum, at a one off cost of approximately $50 million, both at a pre tax level. Capital expenditure is estimated at approximately $100 million. The cost of the moves will be substantially funded from the sale of what will become surplus property in New Zealand and Australia, which is expected to realise approximately $100 million. Additional savings are also anticipated from the sourcing of components from the respective local vendors. Working capital required for the shifts will be globally neutral. The one off costs of the relocations will be substantially provisioned for in the 2008/09 financial year. The Range & DishDrawer factory in Dunedin, New Zealand, along with the......

Words: 1299 - Pages: 6

Der 15. Schläger | TopGirls with *TGirls* | | 2018-12-07 | Salvation