Best Laid Incentive Plan

In: People

Submitted By rshah139
Words 1869
Pages 8
The Best Laid Incentive Plans

Requirements • To analyse the case on the basis of conceptual frameworks discussed in the class.
• Identify main problem, key issues, alternatives and solution/s for the problem identified.
• The related concepts/frameworks should be explained in detail.

Case Analysis

Executive Summary

The case presents an interesting concept of Organizational Behavior and Performance Measurement Systems.

Hiram Phillips CFO and CAO of Rainbarrel Products introduced some changes and the company posted good results due to the same. Hiram felt that he had single-handedly turned the company's performance around. Some of the changes included cost cutting in budget, staff reductions by 10 %, introducing policies for customer care representatives, on time shipment policy etc. At the corporate executive council meeting, where the cost reductions and operating efficiencies were to be discussed and everything looked positive / rosy, until some questions were raised. Although Hiram’s numbers looked remarkable on paper, there were lots of things that Hiram was unaware of that were detrimental to the company as a whole.

The main problem identified in the case is the shortcomings in the Performance Measurement Systems and the necessity to develop a PMS that meets both organizational and individual needs.

Background facts

In the case, “The Best Laid Incentive Plans”, the Chief Financial Officer of Rainbarrel Products, Hiram Phillips, within a year of his being in the company, makes a lot of changes in the prevailing systems, procedures and processes. Using the broad approach of Corporate Governance and narrow focus on the Contemporary Approach to Strategic Control, the case, “The Best Laid Incentive Plans”, may be analyzed as follows:

In this post-modern society, the emerging business forms are geared on…...

Similar Documents

Incentive Plans

...CheckPoint: Incentive Plans Peggy Harrington HRM/240 J. Scott Lodge March 8, 2012 Axia College CheckPoint: Incentive Plans Companies utilize various incentive plans to acquire the best and most skilled employees. The incentive plans can be broken down into individual incentive plans and group incentive plans. Below are a few of the pros and cons for each type. Individual Incentive(s) Piecework Pros - Individuals receive a certain rate for each unit produced Computing rate of pay is simple Labor costs are more accurately predicted Cons - Not an effective motivator Quality may be lacking Standard Hour Plan Pros - Based on “standard time” for job completion, even if completed in less time Best for non-repetitive tasks and requiring varied skills Cons - Quality can suffer due to employees not taking enough time to do the job properly High equipment maintenance due to employees not exercising proper care of the equipment Bonuses/Spot Bonuses Pros - Not part of base pay Typically given at end of year Useful as a retention and motivational tool Cons - Hard to predict labor costs Employees may come to expect the bonus Merit Pay Pros - Based on performance Can be a motivator if increase is large enough Cons - May be perpetuated even if performance declines Employees see it as an......

Words: 441 - Pages: 2

Incentives Plan

... Incentive Plans Travis Green MGT 431 Human Resources Management May 26, 2012 Incentive Plans Providing job satisfaction and incentives for employees should be a priority for employers because incentive pay is often related to job satisfaction. Job satisfaction helps retain valuable employees and contributes to a companies continued success. According to Noe, et al, 2007, “An effective performance plan should be linked to an organizations goal and employees should believe they can meet performance standards.” (Noe, Hollenbeck, Gerhart, & Wright, 2007). This paper will examine incentive plans at EMCOR Mechanical Services and how these plans do or do not help the organization achieve its goals and objectives. At EMCOR Mechanical Services, the organizational objectives are to “go above and beyond promoting a profitable and sustainable business that meets the customers’ expectations, while maximizing opportunities.” The organization also places focus on career satisfaction, integrating employee’s values, integrity, teamwork, effective communication, and empowerment to make the job fun. As a nationwide organization, that continues to grow in a down economy, many employees are committed to the organization. These employees care about the quality of work they produce and are more productive because the company seems to care about them. Salary, flexibility, growth, interpersonal relationships, and a since of value should be taken into consideration when...

Words: 832 - Pages: 4

Best Laid Plans

...Best Laid Plans by Sidney Sheldon Books by Sidney Sheldon IF TOMORROW COMES MASTER OF THE GAME RAGE OF ANGELS BLOODLINE A STRANGER IN THE MIRROR THE OTHER SIDE OF MIDNIGHT THE NAKED FACE WINDMILLS OF THE GODS THE SANDS OF TIME MEMORIES OF MIDNIGHT THE DOOMSDAY CONSPIRACY THE STARS SHINE DOWN NOTHING LASTS FOREVER MORNING, NOON & NIGHT SIDNEY SHELDON THE BEST LAID PLANS HurperCollinsPublishers This novel is entirely a work of fiction. The names, characters and modems portrayed in it are the work of the author's imagination Any resemblance to actual persons, living or dead, events or localities is entirely coincidental. HarperCollinsPuWisfiers 77-85 Fulham Palace Road Hammersmith, London W6 8JU Published by HarperCollinsPuWisfcers 1997 135798642 First published in the USA by William Morrow & Co. ,997 Copyright 6 The Sidney Sheldon Family Limited Partnership 1997 The Author asserts the moral right to be identified as the author of this work A catalogue record for this book is available from the British Library ISBN 0 00 225660 6 ISBN 0 00 225662 2 (airport tpb) Set in Scala Printed and bound in Great Britain by Caledonian International Book Manufacturing Ltd, Glasgow All rights reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system, or transmitted, in any form or by any means, electronic, mechanical photocopymg, recording or otherwise, without the prior permission of the publishers. This book is dedicated to you with my appreciation THE BEST......

Words: 69632 - Pages: 279

Incentive Plans

...Testing OMM 618 Human Resources Management Instructor: Maja Zelihic Laura Thomas, Student November 18, 2013 Employee testing is extremely vital for companies to make certain that the best experienced employees are the ones that are receiving the jobs that have been applied for. Human Resources Departments from companies around the world require making sure the most excellent candidates are appointed in order for the company to maintain to run effortlessly, and not cost the company funds that was used up on the employees who did not remain on the job. Throughout the content of this paper, employee testing will be discusses and what the role of testing is in determining who the precise individual will be for the job opening. There are many reason testing is an important for employment. Testing directs to reduction in the decision-making method. Employment test can be a price useful way to trim down the candidate group. Tests can create the decision method well-organized because fewer times is spent with individuals who characteristics, ability, and aptitude do not equal what is desired. The cost of building the incorrect result is valuable. (Bateson, Wirtz, Burke, & Vaughn, (2013). Organizations a lot of times use test and other procedures to monitor applicants for hire. There are several different types of tests and selection procedures, including cognitive test, personality test, achievement, drug/alcohol, credit check, and criminal background checks.......

Words: 1133 - Pages: 5

Incentive Plan

...Incentive Plan 1 SAMPLE 1 Pratt Nursing Home’s Incentive Plan Introduction Human resource represents the most valuable asset to an organization and it is for this reason that an organization will go to great lengths in keeping its employees satisfied. Employee satisfaction is known to be a factor that can have a significant on the performance of employees and by extension the overall achievement of organizational goals. There are several techniques currently applicable in the field of human resource management that can be put into use to achieve this goal of maintaining a content staff. An incentive plan is one such technique mainly aimed at providing drive to achieve targets (Schoeffler, 2005). Business in the world today has seen the evolution of several plans available for application with widely varied results. An organization may choose to implement one plan or several incentive plans operating at once leaving employee’s to choose plans to pursue based on their individual goals. Despite the fact that all organizations would like to keep a staff that is highly motivated and productive it is not always possible to implement some of the plans based on factors that may be out of the organization’s control. For example, a non profit organization would find it impossible to implement a profit sharing plan. The selection of the incentive plan to use is dependent on the type of business among other factors and if properly implemented can provide a major boost to the......

Words: 1795 - Pages: 8

Why Incentive Plans Cannot Work

...Why Incentive Plans Cannot Work by Alfie Kohn Harvard Business Review Reprint 93506 I N Q U E S T I O N When reward systems fail, don’t blame the program – look at the premise behind it. Why Incentive Plans Cannot Work By Alfie Kohn It is difficult to overstate the extent to which most managers and the people who advise them believe in the redemptive power of rewards. Certainly, the vast majority of U.S. corporations use some sort of program intended to motivate employees by tying compensation to one index of performance or another. But more striking is the rarely examined belief that people will do a better job if they have been promised some sort of incentive. This assumption and the practices associated with it are pervasive, but a growing collection of evidence supports an opposfailure of any given incentive program is due less to a glitch in that program than to the inadequacy of the psychological assumptions that ground all such plans. thinking – those who promote teamwork, participative management, continuous improvement, and the like – urge the use of rewards to institute and maintain these very reforms. What we use bribes to accomplish may have changed, but the reliance on bribes, on behaviorist doctrine, has not. Moreover, the few articles that appear to criticize incentive plans are Temporary Compliance Most managers too often believe in the redemptive power of rewards. ing view. According to numerous studies in laboratories,......

Words: 4865 - Pages: 20

Incentive Plans Paper

...Head: Incentive Plans Paper * * * * * * * * Incentive Plans Paper Myra Callahan University of Phoenix MGT/431 Human Resources Management Brad Bridges March 6th, 2011 The organization’s incentive plans relate to organizational objective because of the involvement of the financial goals for the company. Objectives define strategies or implementation steps to attain the identified goals. Unlike goals, objectives are specific, measurable, and have a defined completion date. They are more specific and outline the “who, what, when, where, and how” of reaching the goals. The development of the objectives will be to help achieve goals by dividing them into manageable components (Workforce Development, 2009). Therefore, the objectives and incentive plans go hand in hand. Incentive Plans Incentive plans are not successful when it is extremely broad and is not created for the employees or staff members. There is a saying, “all for one and one for all,” that is no longer effectively accepted into the business world. It definitely discourages those trying their best in their job performances. This certain style of increase sharing is like an entitlement. Being that some employees slack in their performances, the productive employees will reject that style of incentives. Everyone must have a clear understanding of the incentive compensation and how it connects to his or her effort. A well thought out compensation plan will......

Words: 905 - Pages: 4

Incentive Plan Paper

...Employee Relations: Incentive Plans Paper Katrina J. King MGT/431 - Human Resources Management University of Phoenix July 19, 2011 Dr. Cassandra Molavrh Employee Relations: Incentive Plans Paper Money motivates employees. Cold hard cash. Cash money will always and forever be the most important factor in motivating employees. However, money is not the only solution. Developing solid incentive techniques for Texas Sports Beat require the organization to take a deeper look within the organizational culture to find ways to offer and introduce the ‘Incentives Plan Program.’ “How can the organization attract and keep quality staff ensuring everyone is involved and interested?” As mentioned in the above paragraph, cash is not always the answer and in countless cases not even the best response. According to the Law of Individual Differences; People differ in abilities, needs, personality, and values. Thus people react to different incentives in different ways. Because TSB Sports, is a small organization, it cannot afford to pay salary wages to employees. The organization employs contract workers to perform specific tasks. For an example: A staff photographer would be paid hourly wages per game worked.. Usually, three to 12 games per week (home games only). Photographers are paid by the hour, no matter staff, or freelance. Photographer’s incentives are opportunities to take images of players and......

Words: 799 - Pages: 4

Incentive Plans

...Incentive Plans Paper LaKesha Lightfoot MGT/431 [ May 22, 2011 ] David Van Gorder Incentive Plans Paper Incentive plans are developed to encouraged motivation. Motivation comes in various forms, but most commonly in the form of money. Individuals find motivation by both recognition and money, which is the reason employers develop incentive plans that will appeal to both groups. Within this paper, incentive plans and how they relate to organizational objectives are reviewed. Whether those plans do or do not help the organization achieve its goals and objectives is also reviewed. Incentive plans Fittings Unlimited, Incorporated (FUI) has not considered the benefits of incentive plans. Therefore, employees have become inactive and lackadaisical. As individuals work and perform their job, it becomes second nature causing excitement and interest to fade. In an industry such as hydraulics, business functions at high speed and everyday needs are three days too late, employees need encouragement to keep going. Overworked employees who are under compensated make the need for motivational strategies more prevalent. Customer service, the essential element of an organizations growth process depends heavily on the employees administering excellent customer service. Motivating those employees with commission earnings from each sale would help ensure employees are performing at optimal levels. Commission earnings would show employees the value their employer put on......

Words: 677 - Pages: 3

Best Plans

...Best Plans! A pretty and wealthy woman was serving life sentence in prison. Angry and resentful about her plight she had decided that she would rather die than to live another year in prison. Over the years she had become good friends with one of the prison caretakers. His job, among others, was to bury those prisoners who died in a graveyard just outside the prison walls. When a prisoner died, the caretaker rang a bell,which was heard by everyone.  The caretaker then got the body and put it in a casket. Next, he entered his office to fill out the death certificate before returning to the casket to nail the lid shut. Finally, he put the casket on a wagon to take it to the graveyard and bury it. Knowing this routine, the woman devised an escape plan and shared it with the caretaker; The next time the bell rang, the woman would leave her cell and sneak into the dark room where the coffins were kept. She would slip into the coffin with the dead body while the caretaker was filling out the death certificate.. When the care-taker returned, he would nail the lid shut and take the coffin outside the prison with the woman in the coffin along with the dead body. He would then bury the coffin. The woman having pre-arranged with the caretaker for special vents in the coffin knew there would be enough air for her to breathe until later in the evening when the caretaker would return to the graveyard under the cover of darkness, dig up the coffin, open it, and set her free.  ...

Words: 687 - Pages: 3

Incentive Plan Paper

...Incentive plans paper Marques King MGT/431 October 18, 2011 University Of Phoenix Tracy Garmer Incentive plans paper In this essay I will discuss how organization’s incentive plans relate to organizational objectives. Second, I will evaluate how the incentive plans do, or do not help the organization to achieve its goals and objectives. Along with wages and salary, many organizations offer incentive pay which is designed to energize, direct, or control employee’s behavior. Incentive pay is effective, because the amount paid is linked to certain behaviors or outcomes (Noe, R. A. Hollenbeck, J. R., Gerhart, B. & Wright, P. M. 2007). The way to integrate employee incentive plans with organizational objectives is to focus on incentives the activities that are relevant to achieve the desired objectives, rather than basing it things such as seniority or organizational politics (Ingram, D. ehow contributor 2011). There are many reasons why an employee incentive plan was created such as, employee recognition, cash or non-cash incentives, eligibility, and performance measures. Some incentive plans only offer positive recognition for employees who can reach their goals under the plan. This type of incentive plan will not motivate most people to want to reach their goals. A study from People Performance Management and Measurement found that most managers use employee recognition as their incentive plan. Managers can also design a special program to......

Words: 624 - Pages: 3

Case 4- Best Laid Incentive Plans

...from all levels of the organization. The data and information generated should be discussed face-to-face. The control system should be a key catalyst for an ongoing debate about underlying data, assumptions, and action plans. Hiram should first go directly to the workers and ask them what the issues are and what is they think is causing the issues. After getting this information from the workers Hiram should take it to the senior management and discuss some ideas for resolving the issue. Instead of stopping at coming up with a strategy to resolve the issue, Hiram should go back to the workers and make sure that the strategy is resolving their issues and also make sure that the strategy is not causing any more issues. When Hiram has done all he can to help the workers complete their job accurately he should then began to measure the success which will be long term. When the employees see how involved Hiram is in their success they will try their best to continue to be successful. With a great employee relationship Hiram would not have to worry about employees trying to find ways around doing the right things. As long as the employees know how their role affects the entire company, they are not overworked, and that they are appreciated they will want to do their best and they will succeed....

Words: 2001 - Pages: 9

Incentive Plans

...Companies use incentive plans as a way to motivate and compensate employees’ remarkable levels of professional accomplishment. It can also be a used to boost production levels and reward employees for a job well done. The objective of incentives awards is to motivate employee goal-setting, cooperation, and group interaction. For the most employees will perform according to how they are measured and compensated. When employees work as a team, they should be paid as a team. And if the employees don’t get compensated as a team they probably won’t performed as a team. Business has different incentives awards, these incentives can begin at the beginning of a pay period, quarter or the start of the year. Employees could receive a lump-sum payment ranging from $100.00 to $10,000 or Time-Off Award. According to online source “Compensation alone won’t guarantee high levels of performance; however, reward programs can produce the behaviors most likely to lead to success. Employees living more balanced lives tend to be more productive.” (Caruth & Caruth, 2013) The Academic Journal, Team Performance Management was written by Jody R. Hoffman and Steven G. Rogelberg. In this Journal the authors wrote the article “A Guide to Team Incentive Systems” the article was about the seven major categories of a team incentive plan. The seven categories are: 1) team gainsharing profit-sharing, 2) team goal-based incentive systems. 3) Team discretionary bonus systems, 4) team skill incentive......

Words: 592 - Pages: 3

Incentive Plans

...Incentive Plans MGT/431 February 21, 2012 Incentive Plans Organizations provide incentive plans to employees as motivation to reach the objectives and goals of the company. Incentives are given to personnel to encourage them to do his or her best. Incentive plans in any business might include bonuses or raises, stock option plans, or other forms of incentives. This is in exchange for the employees who work harder, better, or faster in accordance with the organizations goals and objectives (, 2001). The majority of incentives are performance-based policies in which workers receive additional cash or benefits centered on a worker’s performance. Raises and Bonuses Most companies will award a base salary increase that is dependent on several factors, including job classification, your individual performance, your company's overall financial performance, and your company's salary structure (, 2012). Bonuses and annual incentive payouts depend primarily on two variables: your job performance and your company's overall financial performance. Depending on your job, these programs can vary in complexity and payout (, 2012). Each year employee’s at Aetna are given bonuses and raises based on how well the company does. If an employee receives a three or higher on his or her year-end scorecard they are eligible for the bonus and raise. During the month of February employees are contacted by their manager who advises them what his or her......

Words: 939 - Pages: 4

Incentive Plans

...Incentive Plans Most companies use incentive plans in order to retain their current employees and also help recruit new employees. By offering yearly raises, a bonus structure, and performance reviews, employees can be more motivated to perform better and be a valued asset within the company. RealManage does offer incentive plans for each employee however, they are inconsistent to everyone. Most property management companies offer a 3%-5% annual raise each year to help compensate with inflation. RealManage promotes this plan when recruiting new employees. They promote highly competitive pay and place employees on a career path. The president of the branch informs each employee what the career path might be and a timeline is provided. tresero ( 2009), “No one size fits all incentive plan exists”. There are different plans for each employee when it comes to compensation. All hourly employees are presented with unlimited over-time and the ability to charge back all the mileage that you have while commuting back and forth to anything business related. Salary employees are presented with flex time and have the ability to not only charge back mileage but anything that is out of the scope of the contract between the homeowner’s association and the management company. The only difference is when an employee is hired on with RealManage, the compensation incentive suddenly changes. The hourly employees are not allowed to accrue over time hours once the meeting is over. So if an......

Words: 813 - Pages: 4

Bakemonogatari | Dragon Ball – Bảy Viên Ngọc Rồng chap 370 | Construção e Fabricação