Can We Know When to Trust Our Emotions in the Pursuit of Knowledge? Consider History and One Other Area of Knowledge.

In: Philosophy and Psychology

Submitted By tassjaisabelle
Words 1926
Pages 8
Can we know when to trust our emotions in the pursuit of knowledge? Consider history and one other area of knowledge.

Candidate Name: Nastassja Isabelle
Session Number: 002636-063
School Name: Binus International School Simprug
Session: May 2013
Word Count: 1598

“The sign of an intelligent people is their ability to control their emotions by the application of reason”, American author, Marya Mannes once said. Emotion is defined as a strong feeling deriving from one’s circumstances, mood, or relationships with others. In the pursuit of knowledge, there are times when emotion could be involved in order to gain a better understanding of a certain aspect. However, relying on emotions too much could also cloud our judgment, for it is a very subjective way of knowing. This essay will discuss how reliable our emotion is in the pursuit of knowledge in two areas of knowledge; history and the arts. To start with, emotion plays a big part in judging historical figures and events that were immortalized through history books. The question is, would it be accurate enough to judge them solely based on our emotions? Take Richard III for example. He is known as an evil deformed hunchback in history. Shakespeare had popularized Richard III’s ‘deformed hunchback’ image by his famous historical tragedy titled “Richard III” where he was portrayed as a king who ruthlessly lies, murders, and manipulates, so many people had viewed Richard III like that. Shakespeare’s “Richard III” was one of the plays I had to study in my Literature and Performance class, so I knew the character of Richard well enough to judge him. From the play, I perceived Richard III as a heartless evil monster which has greatly affected my judgment to his figure as a king. I learned from the play that he had done countless evil misconducts during his reign, which made me feel pity for the people who were…...

Similar Documents

Consider the Extent to Which Knowledge Issues in Ethics Are Similar to Those in at Least One Other Area of Knowledge

...Knowledge is of great importance for humans to survive, since it provides us with some rules of how to deal with the world. Rules and norms, in turn, are the main subject matter of ethics. This is why all areas of knowledge can be connected with ethics. History, Mathematics, Human sciences and others support kind of ethics, but to what extent do all of these help people to understand morality and make the right decisions? Knowing sometimes can be an advantage or disadvantage depending on the circumstances. In the case of ethics it could help or hinder people knowing what to do. On the other hand, we all search for the real life reasons which will lead us the right way. Knowledge issues are sometimes controversial in Ethics, because quite often there is a conflict between two or more branches of, for example between social morality and the religious morality. Each person accepts and follows different kind of moral rules, under different cirsumstances. The controversies in the society what is right and what is wrong are huge. We either support some rules or do not. People often argue about their beliefs, no matter if they are religious or not. Such example could be given in history. To clarify, history is the study of the human past. It is a field of research which uses a narrative to examine and analyse the sequence of historical events, and it sometimes attempts to investigate objectively the patterns of cause and effect that determine past events. On the other hand,......

Words: 1210 - Pages: 5

To What Extent Do We Need Evidences to Support Our Beliefs in Different Areas of Knowledge?

...THE CATHEDRAL VIDYA SCHOOL LONAVALA TOPIC NUMBER: 4 To what extent do we need evidences to support our beliefs in different areas of knowledge? Candidate Name: Gandhi, shelly Candidate Session Number: 004669-015 Session: May 2011 Word count: 1548 Shelly Gandhi 2 "It is not what the man of science believes that distinguishes him, but how and why he believes it. His beliefs are tentative, not dogmatic; they are based on evidence, not on authority or intuition."1 As truly said by Bertrand Russell, it is considerable to call evidence as one of the basis for a belief. At first sight, evidence seems to be core of many beliefs as most of our practical life is based upon it. However, on a deeper look, the phrase “To what extent” suggests that there may be a limit to the dependence of beliefs on evidences. Indeed, there are several thought provoking questions to this statement- are beliefs always based on evidence? Is there something called perception, inner voice, gut feel or sixth sense (I will call this „intuition‟)? Nevertheless, the answers to these questions lie in nature of the subject and to explain the same, I first need to describe meaning of evidence and belief. In general, Evidence is defined as a piece of information that forms ground for any theory, belief or conclusion. On the other hand, beliefs are defined as certain set of values or perceptions of a person. By definition itself, it is clear that Evidence is also the base (ground) for belief but......

Words: 1887 - Pages: 8

When Should We Trust Our Senses to Give Us Truth?

...begin with, my understanding of trust and the definition that will define my essay is that trust is to place confidence in something or someone, which in this instance is something – our senses. For example, everyday I place trust in my driver Seth’s ability to maneuver and speed through Ghanaian traffic without crashing, a remarkable feat as traffic here is impossibly disorganized. No matter the danger, I always get back in the car with him; that is trust, this could also be considered a necessary risk, but that is beside the point. Moreover, truth is an equally multi-definable word. For the purposes of this essay, truth is any fact that, no matter who or what you are, it remains the same. For example, pure water boils at 100 oC at 1.01 x 105 Pa, nobody can deny that no matter whom or what you are, and therefore it is true. In terms of senses, this essay will deal with our human sense perception: sight, touch, hearing, smell, and taste. ​Instinctively, the first turn I take when answering this question is to look at it scientifically. In my IB Physics class we have learned, for example, in terms of science, when we think an object is a certain color, it is actually precisely not that specific color. Color is transmitted through light, light is a wave and each color has a different wavelength that differentiates it from the others. Objects can either absorb or reflect certain colors depending on their wavelengths. Therefore, the color that we see something as, is the color......

Words: 1583 - Pages: 7

Consider the Extent to Which Complete Certainty Might Be Achievable in Mathematics and at Least One Another Area of Knowledge.

...Mathematicians have the concept of rigorous proof, which leads to knowing something with complete certainty. Consider the extent to which complete certainty might be achievable in mathematics and at least one another area of knowledge. When we look at it at first mathematics and history seems to be two areas of knowledge where proof leads to absolute certainity on the subject. A large proportion of people believe that in history that if there is an evidence based on a claim , whether big or small, then the claim is true. But the actual thing is if there is a proof based on a claim it gives us an idea about the claim and the rest we will have to figure out with our own perception and reasoning skills. Mathematics is comparatively free of all other ways of knowing other than reasoning. Certainty in mathematics need not always be achieved through proof. Consider the case of axioms. Consider the axiom which suggests that things that are equal to same thing are equal to one another. There is actually no formal proof which backs up this axiom or any other axiom. It is just right under your nose. Although it is said rigorous proof leads to complete certainty in mathematics, as we look more deep into the areas of knowledge the level of uncertainity increases. Proof in mathematics is completely different from proof in history. The definition of proof differs in both the contexts. In mathematics proof, refers to a multitude of theorems and......

Words: 1011 - Pages: 5

Pursuit of Knowledge in It Management

...My Pursuit of Knowledge in Information Technology Management I am currently in the Master’s program pursuing a degree in Business Information with a concentration in Information Technology Management. As a University of Phoenix Alumni, I received both my Associates and Bachelor degrees in Information Technology due to my love of computers and the rapid growth of information management. I remember back when graduating from high school, in 1984, computer rooms threw around terms like FORTRAN, COBOL, UNIX, and MS-DOS. The departments worked separately to themselves as if in some elite cult, with high regard to the work they performed and no cross interactions or exchange of knowledge to the other departments. Today, information technology is so much more. Information Technology Managers interact freely and effortlessly with other departments to insure that the most important aspect of the business, its data resources, are secure, accessible, and relevant to the needs of the organizations. Managing this information is what drives my passion for technology. I have had the opportunity to intern within several Information Technology positions and database management appeals to my inner core. I like the idea of being able to leverage the data and knowledge that flows within an organization in order to increase the value of that organization for the benefit of the consumer or the community in which it operates and create increased value within the organization. My......

Words: 420 - Pages: 2

In What Ways May Disagreement Aid the Pursuit of Knowledge in the Natural and Human Sciences?

...to make the knowledge question that entitles this essay easier to understand, the “pursuit of knowledge” needs to be defined. The pursuit of knowledge is a famous term to define the inherent concept of humanity’s constant desire to know more. Personally this topic appeals to me as I have seen the substantial curiosity that children possess, but I believe this thirst for knowledge is very limited. All children want to hear is an answer, but they don’t question the sources or ask to see the evidence. When I noticed this trait in young children, I had an epiphany that if our global society followed this childish outlook on the world, the world and the education system wouldn’t be the same. I will elaborate upon two possible perspectives towards this question; either you believe that disagreement does aid the pursuit of knowledge or you believe that it doesn’t. I will demonstrate both perspectives by analyzing how the roles of logic and emotion help gain new knowledge in the sciences. Ideally the role of logic is applied towards the natural sciences, and the human sciences use emotion as a way of knowing. I believe that disagreement in the natural and human sciences opens up the opportunity to question what has been asserted, in order to ameliorate our current Truths, but there are cases where this same disagreement rather hinders the pursuit of an “underlying truth”. The first perspective agrees with the statement above, that disagreement aids the pursuit of knowledge in the......

Words: 1581 - Pages: 7

Knowledge Management

...Management knowledge and knowledge management: realism and forms of truth John Mingers1 1Kent Business School, University of Kent, Canterbury, U.K. Correspondence: John Mingers, Kent Business School, University of Kent, Canterbury, Kent, CT2 7PE, U.K. Tel: þ44 1227 824008; E-mail: j.mingers@kent.ac.uk Received: 24 July 2007 Accepted: 15 October 2007 Abstract This paper addresses the issue of truth and knowledge in management generally and knowledge management in particular. Based on ideas from critical realism and critical theory, it argues against the monovalent conceptualization of knowledge implicitly or explicitly held by many authors and aims instead to develop a characterization that recognizes the rich and varied ways in which human beings may be said ‘to know’. It points out and conceptualizes a fundamental dimension of knowledge that is generally ignored or cursorily treated within the literature, that is, ‘truth’. It identifies four forms of knowledge – propositional, experiential, performative and epistemological – and explores their characteristics, especially in terms of truth and validity. It points out some implications for knowledge management. Knowledge Management Research & Practice (2008) 6, 62–76. doi:10.1057/palgrave.kmrp.8500161 Keywords: knowledge management; knowledge; information; critical realism; critical theory; truth Introduction Although knowledge management (KM) has established itself as a bona fide subject both in......

Words: 13749 - Pages: 55

The Dis-Pursuit of Knowledge

...America has become more and more centered on entertainment. What was once an intellectually strong nation has transformed into one that is ruled by the media and whose intelligence is quickly deteriorating. Now, essentially every part of daily life must be entertaining for Americans to pay any attention, whether it is politics, religion, or basic communication. Neil Postman’s Amusing Ourselves to Death proclaims that public discourse has become entertainment, leading to apathetic generations; moreover, this causes the overall degeneration of knowledge. As society moves away from text-based intellectualism and becomes less caring, it becomes more susceptible to media persuasion. Television and Internet can change opinions and notions with little effort. This can be seen through commercials, market advertising, as well as elections. In one case, Ramsey Clark was challenging Jacob Javits for his New York Senate seat. Clark used position papers to reach out to the public and show them his policies. Javits mainly used thirty-second television commercials. The commercials appealed to the instantaneous public: "He [Javits] won the election by the largest plurality in New York State history" (Postman 130). Society would much rather watch commercials and let them become the basis of its opinions than read researched position papers. The media wins out. This can also be seen in the modern day with so-called humanitarians attempting to help those who are miserable. A prime example is......

Words: 1184 - Pages: 5

That Which Is Accepted as Knowledge Today Is Sometimes Discarded Tomorrow”. Consider Knowledge Issues Raised by This Statement in Two Areas of Knowledge.

...That which is accepted as knowledge today is sometimes discarded tomorrow”. Consider knowledge issues raised by this statement in two areas of knowledge. School Name: The International School Candidate Name: Muhammad Jamal Teacher Name: Syeda Sobia Haleem Candidate Code: 001307-0019 Session: 2012-2014 Word Count: 1234 “That which is accepted as knowledge today is sometimes discarded tomorrow”. Consider knowledge issues raised by this statement in two areas of knowledge. If today, someone came up and said that the universe is motionless, he would be considered a lunatic. But in 1917, it was a common phenomenon widely believed that the universe was static. Until Einstein presented his theory and explained how the solar system worked. This example raises a knowledge issue: “Can we say that the knowledge attained through reasoning and perception is immutable”? Because the aforementioned example completely refuted this idea. What is knowledge? Knowledge is a combination of random information. This is systematically arranged through different ways of knowing specially reasoning and perception. Knowledge is classified as a factual belief. It is indispensable that the statement is considered to be true by all- which is objectivity. Having said that, we cannot ignore the role of Subjectivity in the formation of knowledge. After taking the limitations of ways of......

Words: 1304 - Pages: 6

That Which Is Accepted as Knowledge Today Is Sometimes Discarded Tomorrow.” Consider Knowledge Issues Raised by This Statement in Two Areas of Knowledge.(Question #4)

...accepted as knowledge today is sometimes discarded tomorrow.” Consider knowledge issues raised by this statement in two areas of knowledge.(Question #4) Technological advancements and increasing globalization in our world have led to vast improvements in the access and diffusion of knowledge in almost every single society. The statement, “That which is accepted as knowledge today is sometimes discarded tomorrow.” raises certain issues about the nature of knowledge and the implications of knowledge as we know it. Hence, it will be my aim to explore whether or not knowledge can be the same for everyone, and to investigate the timelessness of knowledge, questioning if it is actually possible to discard knowledge. The scope of this essay will focus on the natural sciences and human sciences in terms of Areas of Knowledge (AoK), and reason, perception, and language within the various Ways of Knowing (WoK). Whilst I realise that perhaps any AoK could have been utilized to explore the extent to which knowledge is personal or shared, the natural and human sciences lend themselves particularly well to this investigation due to the prominent role of inductivism in both these AoK. The five key steps to inductivism; observation, hypothesis, experiment, law, and theory require the use of perception and reason to validate knowledge in these AoK, and hence the aforementioned WoK become distinctly useful in the analysis of this knowledge issue.......

Words: 1632 - Pages: 7

In Gaining Knowledge, Each Area of Knowledge Uses a Network of Ways of Knowing

...GAINING KNOWLEDGE, EACH AREA OF KNOWLEDGE USES A NETWORK OF WAYS OF KNOWING KQ What does it mean to know? THESIS The two areas of knowledge are history and art and the ways that will be connected to them are memory, emotion, reason, imagination and faith. ROAD MAP I’ll approach my topic with connecting reality to ways of knowing and areas of knowledge using real life situations. CLAIM The only two ways in which humankind can produce knowledge is through passive observation or active experiment. Active learning is where the learner queries the world in the search of knowledge. Passive learning is where the learner has no control over the knowledge that presents itself. EXPLANATION Taking other knowledge is as data, by logical operation knowledge can be inferred for example. Testimony which is knowledge based on the acceptance of testimony involves accepting what others say . “There are only two ways in which humankind can produce knowledge: through passive observation or through active experiment." I agree with this quote because gaining knowledge from others and learning from them is passive observation while active experiment is actually experiencing something in order to gain knowledge in the situation. COUNTERCLAIM We don’t just produce knowledge we also discover it, like dinosaurs we didn’t produce them we discovered them. EXPLAINATION Creation is more discovery or giving meaning at least with respect to knowledge. It not like we produced knowledge......

Words: 799 - Pages: 4

"When the Only Tool You Have Is a Hammer, All Problems Begin to Resemble Nails.” (Abraham Maslow) How Might This Apply to Ways of Knowing, as Tools, in the Pursuit of Knowledge?

...TOK Essay "When the only tool you have is a hammer, all problems begin to resemble nails.” (Abraham Maslow) How might this apply to ways of knowing, as tools, in the pursuit of knowledge?
 Have you ever wondered why and how your logic becomes restricted once confronting a problem? Abraham Maslow once stated “I suppose it is tempting, if the only tool you have is a hammer, to treat everything as if it were a nail”, which I believe could be understood as a statement questioning the method diverse human beings follow to execute any of their tasks. In this essay, integrating the functions of human intuition, language vs. sense perception and reasoning in contrast with mathematics, ethics and emotions, will help providing an answer for “To what extent should we trust our fundamental skills into resolving all types of complications”. Further more, by staying in correlation with Maslow’s statement, we should come to conclusion that a human being isn’t always conscious of his actions and that it takes high self-control and creativity when in need of solving a problem. As far as I can see, encountering a problem that necessitates an approval and a final decision to be made usually requires the usage of intuition. In other words, the process in the making of a decision cannot start before a problem has actually been set. The type of problem worth being investigated, must have first been lead by an intuition, which subsequently triggers the last......

Words: 1626 - Pages: 7

‘the Vocabulary We Have Does More Than Communicate Our Knowledge; It Shapes What We Can Know’. Evaluate This Claim with Reference to Different Areas of Knowledge.

...‘The vocabulary we have does more than communicate our knowledge; it shapes what we can know’. Evaluate this claim with reference to different areas of knowledge. As a unique language designed for every area of study, vocabulary is an important bridge linking us to the understanding of certain knowledge. Many people consider vocabulary as the foundation of knowledge. If we wish to master a certain area, the prerequisite is acquiring an extensive range of vocabulary in that specific area. This is because by enhancing the vocabulary, we are able to do more than identify the knowledge; we are capable of proceeding to a higher level of understanding. However, we usually see vocabulary as mere words and expressions. What we do not realise is the possibilities and underlying potentials that vocabulary can create. Mathematics is in the core of many fields of knowledge. Even now we are surrounded by the application of math. Once, I was asked: what is mathematics? Most people, in fact, even I myself answered numbers, equations and formulas. What a majority felt was mathematics is just a way of manipulating numbers by relating them to one another. Can mathematics, such a beautiful and wise knowledge, be defined in a few and simple words? When I was introduced to Einstein’s famous mass-energy equation, E=mc2, in one of my classes, then only I realised how wrong I was. My definition for mathematics was actually the vocabulary of math. In the context of physics, the mathematical......

Words: 1301 - Pages: 6

Emotion (Theory of Knowledge)

...[Emotion] has the advantage of being open to all, the weak and the lowly, the illiterate and the scholar. It is seen to be as efficacious as any other method and is sometimes said to be stronger than the others, since it is its own fruition, while other methods are means to some other ends. I questioned this statement in regards to the ‘it is its own fruition’ part. I interpreted this part to mean that emotion can just be emotion. It does not lead anywhere, to another answer like reasoning something out would. For example, in math I use reason to figure problems out while, as I understand this statement, when I feel happy, I just stay that way because emotion is its own end result. I don’t agree with this idea. Emotion is not its own fruition as the statement suggests; rather, I think that emotions always lead to something more. A brain imaging study by University College London suggests that emotions almost completely rule decision making. Emotions cannot possibly just be emotions because of the millions of decisions we make every day. This morning, I decided to get up and make my bed. I decided whether to eat first or shower first. Then I decided what clothing to wear and in the bathroom whether to shampoo first or soap first. There were so many little decisions in between those pertaining to how much to feed my cat and where to set my clothes down while I took a shower. If everything I decided was mostly based on emotions, then how can an emotion just be an emotion?......

Words: 704 - Pages: 3

To What Extent Do We Need Evidence to Support Our Beliefs in Different Areas of Knowledge?

...The human race tends to have a variety of beliefs throughout both concrete and abstract areas of knowledge, in this essay I will explore to what degree beliefs need evidence. Using examples, I will focus on the following knowledge issues; does our perception of evidence justify our beliefs? And are we able to have beliefs without evidence? Noticeably, all areas of knowledge are benefited by support from evidence. It is a question of how much evidence is needed for sufficient support. The title holds many concepts that can be explored in different ways. ‘Beliefs’ can be described as spontaneous occurrences of vivid ideas in the mind’ (Pojman). More abstract areas of knowledge such as art can adopt this meaning as they require less ‘evidence’ ;being subjective means that it does not necessarily require physical proof. ‘Beliefs can also be caused by experiencing things in constant conjunction to each other’ (Pojman). This depicts the fact that belief is more of a ‘reasoned process.’ More concrete areas of knowledge like Human and Natural sciences will usually follow this meaning. Science is a methodical process in which we experiment to test theories which constantly use evidence. ‘Evidence’ can be defined as the ‘availability of facts or information indicating whether a ‘belief’ or proposition is true or valid’. In this definition we already see that evidence demands physical proof. However, evidence is not limited to the physical state. For example, religion is individual......

Words: 1286 - Pages: 6

- Tumbbad (2018) Proper HDRip - 720p - Original (DD5 1) [Telugu + Tamil + Hin... | Jim Profit - Ein Mann geht über Leichen | ++ 4 x schöne ältere Tapeten - Rollen - Sesamstrasse - ++