Critisim for Yellow Wallpaper

In: English and Literature

Submitted By noneed4that
Words 2869
Pages 12
Karla J. Murphy

Pedagogy, Volume 4, Issue 2, Spring 2004, pp. 337-343 (Article)

For additional information about this article Access provided by SULTAN QABOOS UNIVERSITY (29 Dec 2014 03:14 GMT)

The Pedagogical Possibilities of Covering Gilman’s Wallpaper
Karla J. Murphy

In his introduction to The Pedagogical Wallpaper, Jeffrey Andrew Weinstock notes how the pedagogical diversity of Charlotte Perkins Gilman’s “The Yellow Wall-Paper” prompted him to collect essays for this book. He goes on to explain that “given the ubiquity of the text within various academic settings, I was also struck by the absence of attention to the text within pedagogical contexts. Despite the large (and steadily growing) body of criticism to the story, very little of it explicitly addresses its importance as a tool to facilitate learning or various ways in which to make use of the text in the classroom” (3). As a collection, Weinstock’s The Pedagogical Wallpaper contains informed, detailed, and diverse analysis that attempts to shore up the absence of “pedagogical possibilities” concerning Gilman’s transgressive short story (9). Among the contributors are a MOO space specialist, a Gilman scholar, a queer theorist, an existentialist, a formalist, and several reader/student-response theorists. Because each essayist presents a distinct critical perspective on Gilman’s text, each essay is likewise concerned with “how the narrative teaches and how to teach the narrative” (5). Thus, it seems to me that Weinstock’s The Pedagogical Wallpaper resonates with Pedagogy’s conviction that teaching is central to our work as scholars and educators, no matter what our particular perspective. Indeed, Weinstock’s commitment to diverse and instructive pedagogical prompts is persuasive and liberating, affording ample avenues for new…...

Similar Documents

The Yellow Wallpaper

...Ashley Buhana Holly Carey English 1302-16 March 19, 2007 No Way Out In Charlotte Perkins Gilman’s “The Yellow Wallpaper”, the narrator struggles with her identity and her place in society. The role of women in nineteenth century American society is depicted as irrelevant and inferior to men. This includes the relationship between husband and wives, the social and economic reliance of women on men, and the suppression of female individuality and sexuality. She lives with her high standing physician husband John and their baby. Jennie, their housekeeper and John’s sister, is there most of the time looking after the baby and doing household chores. In the beginning of the story, the narrator is suffering from post partum depression; however, towards the end of the story her depression turns into insanity. John’s condescending mind-set and physical control worsen her condition. During the early nineteenth century, a woman’s role was to care for the home and her family; however, the narrator in this story isn’t even able to socialize with her family. John talks down to and belittles his wife. He says, “Bless her little heart! […] She shall be sick as she pleases! But now let’s improve the shining hours by going to sleep, and talk about it in the morning” (578). John’s condescension leads to a conflict inside the narrator’s mind between her growing understanding of her own weakness and her desire to suppress......

Words: 858 - Pages: 4

Yellow Wallpaper

...The Yellow Wallpaper: Narrator’s Perception Of Reality "The color is hideous enough and unreliable enough and infuriating enough, but the pattern is torturing. You think you have mastered it, but just as you get well underway in following, it turns a back-somersault and there you are. It slaps you in the face, knocks you down, and tramples upon you." (Gildman, p. 71) The story of the Yellow Wallpaper tells us about the madness of the “nameless” main character as she is suffering from a nervous depression. Her husband john, a physician, takes her to a leased summer home to try to relieve her with rest-cure. Rather than curing his wife from her disorder, John worsens the effects sending her into a severe depression. The role of the yellow wallpaper plays a dominant role in the story reviling her insanity through her writings, her husband’s treatments that worsen her health; and the lady behind the wallpaper. The narration in the Yellow Wallpaper is written in a unique first person point of view. Because of this we are able to see the deterioration of her state throughout the whole story. The narrator of the story is isolated from the outside world only exposed through a barred window to look out. She has no contact with the outside world, except john and their housekeeper Jennie, which leads her to writing. John does not want his wife to write because he thinks it will diminish her treatment, but she does anyway, which is exhausting for her to do it in secret. As the......

Words: 800 - Pages: 4

The Yellow Wallpaper

...Charlotte Gilman’s short story, “The Yellow Wallpaper” is a feminist’s tale of a woman who is spoken to like a child, ignored like a piece of furniture, and treated medically in a way that is horrible to most sensibilities. The horror she tolerates starring at the dreadful wallpaper day after day is really just a side effect of her abuse, and her frustrating lack of fulfillment, which was forbidden by a fool-hardy psychologist and enforced by the patriarchy of her husband. The short story was published in a New England magazine in 1892 and was received with mixed reviews. “Such a story ought not to be written” said one Boston physician. “Another physician, in Kansas, I think, wrote to say that it was the best description of incipient insanity he had ever seen” Crazy, or not, Gilman’s work was quickly recognized for its feminist message. “Gilman's story quickly evolved from a relatively obscure and subversive magazine piece of the late nineteenth century to a formative feminist classic” (St. Jean, 2002,). There are several examples of Gilman being spoken to by her husband the way a parent would speak to an anxious four year-old. “What is it little girl?” he said, “Don’t go walking about like that – you’ll get cold” (Gilman, in Kirszner, 2010, p. 465). “Bless her little heart!” said he with a big hug, “she shall be as sick as she pleases…[go] to sleep, and talk about it in the morning” (p. 466). Thrailkill confirms that The Yellow Wallpaper is indeed a feminist......

Words: 490 - Pages: 2

Yellow Wallpaper

...The Yellow Wallpaper The attitudes towards women’s mental and physical health in the 19thcentury vary greatly from today’s views on practicing medicine. During that time, there was prevalence for the oppression of women and the general treatment for mental illness was a popular method known as resting cures. The short story “The Yellow Wallpaper”, serves as a critique of this popular treatment as it is an account of an unnamed narrator who descends into madness when receiving this type of treatment for her illness. The author, Charlotte Gilman addresses themes of madness and insanity through the narrator’s collection of journal entries, which comprise the story. In the beginning of the story, the narrator is confined to bed rest in a rented house with her physician husband, John, who believes that total rest is in her best interest for her condition. Gilman’s disapproving views over rest cures and doctor/patient relationships are initially revealed through the narrator’s description of her husband. The narrator describes him as a man who “scoffs openly at any talk of things not to be felt and seen and put down in figure”(355) and refuses to see his wife’s illness as a true condition. Through the narrator’s description, Gilman begins to point out the flaws in medicine’s understanding of mental illness and its shortcomings in treatment. The narrator writes in her journal as a way of escape from the monotony and solidarity of her treatment. While she loves and trusts her......

Words: 684 - Pages: 3

The Yellow Wallpaper

...The Yellow Wallpaper The writer Charlotte Perkins Gilman writes the short story ‘’The Yellow Wallpaper’’, in 1899. A period of time where women weren’t allowed to have equal rights or the same opportunities as men had because of the male dominated society. The short story is written in first person narrator with a limited point of view. The narrators’ husband, named John, is a physician and she is very dominated by him. She is mentally ill and her husband always tells her what to not do and in her head she doesn’t agree with his methods ”Personally, I disagree with their ideas”(p. 1, l. 24), but she does it almost as he says anyway. John is a physician why truly believes in physic and that is the reason why he doesn’t consider her as ill, it is not measurable. She is depressed by her duties, she is also nervous and insecure: “But these nervous troubles are dreadfully depressing”(p. 2, l. 37), even though all she wants is to be good and helpful. “I meant to be such a help to John, such a real rest and comfort, and here I am a comparative burden already!”(p. 2, l. 41-42). The narrator is very fragile and she think it’s nearly an impossible thought to be with her baby: “It is fortunate Mary is so good with the baby. Such a dear baby! And yet I cannot be with him, it makes me so nervous.” (p. 3, l. 1-2). This may indicate that she is suffering from a birth depression. Women suffocating from a birth depression are not rare and therefore this could be the illness she is......

Words: 913 - Pages: 4

Yellow Wallpaper

...The Yellow Wallpaper Charlotte Perkins Gilman’s short story, “The Yellow Wallpaper”, highlights the repressed position of most married women during the 19th century. The narrator struggles both at the hands of her family members and internally. Her husband John, a physician, makes an effort to alleviate his wife’s mental state by moving their family into an old style home located in a remote area and isolating her as much as possible. He determines that it is unhealthy for her to entertain, interact with their baby, even to write which she seems to enjoy a great deal. When approaching “The Yellow Wallpaper” one has to keep in mind the importance of the title itself. John decides on their bedroom in the new home and it is covered in yellow wallpaper that the narrator takes great issue with. Using reader response, it is evident that Gilman uses imagery and symbolism to merge the protagonist’s life with that of the “woman” behind the yellow wallpaper. Before an analysis is presented the reader must first understand the marital expectations and male to female dynamic during the time period to which Gilman is writing. Married women faced oppression at the hands of society as well as their husbands. The 1800’s were a time when the wife was to be seen and not heard. It was a general societal expectation that wives if financially secure could have no real issues of their own. This was also because they were not expected to think on their own. They were expected to only reflect the...

Words: 1270 - Pages: 6

Yellow Wallpaper

...of Them All? Has darkness ever covered everything in your room before? How difficult was it to find the path to the door with just a sliver of light coming from underneath the door? Being completely engulfed by darkness can have a negative effect on some individuals after a period of time. As a result of this darkness, the feeling of helplessness begins to be released from one’s body in the shape of a noose as it slowly smothers its prey. Charlotte Perkins Gilman, author of “The Yellow Wallpaper,” is known for her feminist approach in her writings. In the story, husband and physician, John, questions the nameless narrator’s mental state, for he takes her to an isolated house and has prescribed his wife to several months of “the rest cure”. Being kept away from society with only her thoughts and the room she lays in day after day, the narrator slowly begins to question herself and tries to discover her identity within the wallpaper. Gilman uses setting, symbolism, and irony in “The Yellow Wallpaper” to illustrate that the lack of autonomy can negatively affect a person’s mental instability. Because the story takes place in a feminist era, Gilman shows how the husband has complete dominance within the setting of the story. In the beginning, the narrator, whose name is never stated, is brought to a house on the countryside by her husband, John, who happens to be her physician as well. The narrator expresses in her journal, “[The house] is quite alone, standing well back......

Words: 1036 - Pages: 5

The Yellow Wallpaper

...The Yellow Wallpaper – What points is the author making about male/female relationships? One of the main points that is being made about the relationships in this novel is the way in which the male is the more dominant character who controls the female. In the yellow wallpaper it can be seen that John treats the narrator as a child. “What is that little girl?” This shows that John is being very patronizing towards the narrator; the tone used can usually be associated between a father and daughter which could imply that he feels that he is a father figure to her as he cares for her. “Girl” connotes that John feels the narrator I childlike and young; it also shows the mental age difference between the two characters. Furthermore it can be seen that John treats the Narrator as a child from the way in which he acts around her. “Dear John gathered me up in his arms, and just carried me upstairs and laid me on the bed, and sat by me and read to me till it tired my head.” This routine is something a parent would do to their child, for example they usually read to their child until they fall asleep. This is showing that John has control over the narrator and that their relationship could be seen as more of a father and daughter rather than a wife and husband. However on the first page it can be seen that their relationship fits in with the era in which it was written. ‘John laughs at me, of course, but one expects that in marriage.’ This shows the patriarchal society of......

Words: 415 - Pages: 2

Yellow Wallpaper

...The Yellow Wallpaper: An Analytical Summary The story entitled “The Yellow Wallpaper” is about a woman who is believed to be suffering from a mental disease by her spouse and he decided to take her to a place which was quite and therefore, can help her in the recovery process. The husband was a physician and he used his good judgment to make a choice of a room for her wife in the new house. The chosen room was big and airy. The husband thought that his wife will remain comfortable in the room but he never asked her about her choice and softly forced his will upon the lady. The lady however, wanted a room at the ground-floor which was much smaller and cozy. The lady never questioned her husband’s decision and followed his instructions but only to experience a worst possible fate a human can ever imagine (Gilman, 1892). The story tells about how females are guided and literally ruled over by their husbands. The women have remained suppressed in all parts of the world as they were unable to take charge of the life that they had been blessed with by the God himself. Additionally, the choice made by the husband aggravated the issue because the wife fell into the belief that she was trapped into the room and her belief translated into a presence of woman who was trapped into the yellow wallpaper. The wife considered it as her duty to free the trapped woman as she cannot free herself. The will to help others had always remained a great motivational force for humans and......

Words: 543 - Pages: 3

The Yellow Wallpaper

...The Yellow Wallpaper The Yellow Wallpaper Determining Abnormality In The Yellow Wallpaper the woman in question is clearly suffering. She does not get to see her own child, she cries easily, and gets little to no sleep at night because of the wallpaper in the room. “…and I did not make a very good case for myself, for I was crying before I had finished.” (Gilman) This fulfills one of the seven criteria for determining abnormality. The second criteria is Maladaptiveness which is fulfilled throughout the story as she starts to withdraw from her husband and his sister, keeping secrets from them as well as, toward the end of the story, being suspicious of them. “…but it exhausts me a good deal – having to be sly about it,” (Gilman) In the end the woman in the story believes that she ‘escaped’ from the wallpaper this fulfills the third criteria Statistical Deviance. “’I’ve got out at last,’ said I, ‘in spite of you and Jane. And I’ve pulled off most of the paper, so you can’t put me back!’”(Gilman) The fourth criteria, Violations of the Standards of Society, is fulfilled when she tears down the wallpaper although this in and of itself isn’t all that abnormal her reasoning was. “’I’ve got out at last,’ said I, ‘in spite of you and Jane. And I’ve pulled off most of the paper, so you can’t put me back!’”(Gilman) Another way she fulfills this is when she crawls around on the floor at the end of the story which causes her husband to faint. “I kept on creeping just the same,”...

Words: 964 - Pages: 4

The Yellow Wallpaper

... In the short story “The Yellow Wallpaper,” by Charlotte Perkins Gilman, the narrators instability was not taken seriously by her husband. She was trapped in a house, in one small room, which was no where near beneficial to her health, and given the rest cure. In the article that Charlotte Perkins Gilman wrote, “Why I Wrote The Yellow Wallpaper,” she explains her true experience behind the text. She shows how the rest cure and being treated like you’re helpless may just cause someone to become more crazy and lose touch with reality. The narrator is confined in a room which she believes is a nursery and slowly seems to be getting driven more insane as the days go by trapped in this room. She’s originally put in this room on account of her not being mentally healthy, but she only becomes worse. Once she entered the room she assumed it used to be a nursery for a few reasons. She explains, “It was a nursery first and then playroom and gymnasium, I should judge; for the windows are barred for little children, and there are rings and things in the walls” (Gilman, 1899). She truly wasn’t sure what the room was but was using her creativity to try to figure it out and imagine what this mysterious room she was confined to used to be. Some details hint to the room truly being some sort of mental institution or asylum. She was talking to her husband, John, about getting rid of the wallpaper which was driving her crazy, “He said that after the wallpaper changed it would be the......

Words: 1274 - Pages: 6

The Yellow Wallpaper

...The Yellow Wallpaper By: Charlotte Perkins Gilman Conflict is the commotion that is created between characters or their ideas. It could also be the mental dilemma a character might face. In the Yellow Wallpaper, a short story written in the early 1890s in California was able to show a range of conflicts. The Yellow Wallpaper is about a woman who has given birth and is suffering from postpartum depression which was not discovered during that time. The short story is told in the first-person narrative from a woman’s perspective which shows conflict that is created between her and her husband, the society and the yellow wallpaper. The narrator’s mental deterioration is shown in the story clearly and this had created conflicts which the narrator had found her own way of resolving. The major conflict in the Yellow Wallpaper is the conflict between the narrator and her husband. Their conflict is mainly caused by the lack of trust that is inflicted upon their relationship “You see, he does not believe I am sick! And what can one do?” This indicates that the writer’s husband whom is also her doctor doesn’t trust his wife and plays a major role in her ‘nervous breakdown’. “John does not know how much I really suffer. He knows there is no reason to suffer, and that satisfies him.” The husband, John is a controlling husband that babies his wife and has isolated her from the outside world by putting her in a room because of her alleged illness. John is manipulative and......

Words: 1243 - Pages: 5

The Yellow Wallpaper

...The Yellow Wallpaper and the Wallpaper The short story “The Yellow Wallpaper” by Charlotte Perkins Gilman is about a woman (the narrator) who becomes crazy. She loses touch with the outside world because she is isolated in one room in such a large house. In this short story there are two symbols, people and the bedroom who affect the women in many different ways. Some of these things may seem innocent to her but are a little bizarre to us. The theme of this short story is self-expression. This poor woman is dealing with depression and is being forced to hide her fears and anxiety from everyone so it looks like she is winning the battle. The setting of this short story is mostly takes place in her bedroom. Her husband John is a physician and he said she is sick and needs to stay in her room and rest. So she can’t go outside or interactive with anyone or even her newborn baby. In the beginning of the short story she says “[The house] is quite alone standing well back from the road, quite three miles from the village. It makes me think of English places that you read about, for there are hedges and walls and gates that lock, and lots of separate little houses for the gardeners and people." Meaning that the house looks like a quiet place surrounded by no other houses just like her, she was stuck in a quiet room with just herself. Also she said “A colonial mansion, a hereditary estate, I would say a haunted house, and reach the height of romantic felicity- but that......

Words: 1190 - Pages: 5

The Yellow Wallpaper

...Demise through a Wallpaper Charlotte Perkins Gilman’s uncanny short story “The Yellow Wallpaper”, tells the story of an emotionally delicate woman, Jane, who becomes mentally insane after her husband John, a physician, gives her a strong prescription treatment for her postpartum depression. Normal during that time period, Jane is the powerless one in the marriage, and is therefore uncontrollably dominated by her husband. Being in a marriage of complete inequality and male supremacy, Jane becomes severely unstable due to her husband’s need to control her freedom and life as well as close-minded diagnosis and treatment for her. In turn, John, the dominating figure in the marriage, provokes Jane’s mental collapse through his decisions to overtake Jane’s freedom. Jane’s descent to madness is caused by a number of factors all linked to her husband’s actions. Rather than treating his equal partner Jane, as his equal partner, John treats her as child, as though she is beneath him. One can get this understanding when Jane explains how her husband “took [her] in his arms and called [her] a blessed little goose” (131). These words would normally make one feel emotionally week and therefore embarrassed. She is being spoken to as though she were a small child and not a grown woman capable of independence. Jane becomes affected by this constant behavior of her husband leading her to ignore her own wants and desires, She states that “it is as airy and comfortable a......

Words: 819 - Pages: 4

Yellow Wallpaper

...Justin Weber Professor Stover English 1302 Paper A/ 3:00 05/03/2014 “The Yellow Wall-Paper” “The Yellow Wall-Paper” by Charlotte Perkins Gilman is a story about a woman who moves to a house with her physician husband, John, who orders her to rest to help with her “nervousness.” After a while of being alone, she begins to see a woman coming out of the mysterious wallpaper and becomes obsessive. Near the end of their rental, she locks herself in the room to pull down the wallpaper and free the woman trapped inside. As John arrives and unlocks the door, he faints upon seeing his wife. The story concludes with the woman circling the room, stepping over her husband. The central idea is to show how when one is oppressed and denied the opportunity to be free, it can often have dangerous side effects. "The Story of an Hour" "The Story of an Hour" by Kate Chopin is the story of Mrs. Louise Mallard, a woman with a heart condition, whose sister has arrived at her house to inform her of the death of her husband, Brently. Mrs. Mallard immediately bursts into tears crying into her sister's arms before retreating by herself to a vacant room. Once inside the room, Mrs. Mallard becomes overwhelmed with joy at the thought of the freedom she will now have. As Mrs. Mallard leaves the room, the front door is opened and Mr. Mallard unexpectedly walks in, unaware that he was thought to be dead. Mrs. Mallard, at the sight of her husband, is overcome by her heart condition and......

Words: 1247 - Pages: 5

Multicultural Education - 967 Words | The Kids Are Alright Season 1 Episode 1 | cascata alta 18cm con motore acqua vera presepe x pastori crib shepherds gia 10