Ethical Issues in Three Economies: China, Jamaica, and the U.S.A.

In: Business and Management

Submitted By haggleboz
Words 632
Pages 3
Ethical Issues in Three Economies: China, Jamaica, and the U.S.A.
Ethical issues arise in many different forms across very different cultural, economic and even geographic situations. In a paper written by Lillian Fok, et al, the question is raised whether participants in three significantly varied economies will tend to have similar responses to ethical questions encountered during typical business scenarios. Business professionals from China, Jamaica, and the United States were presented with situations and ethically questionable decisions (and in some cases, illegal). The subjects were then asked how likely they would have been to make the same choices and their probable justifications. The researchers found both similarities and distinct differences that they concluded can be attributed to cultural and environmental variations between the respondents’ countries of origin.
Five different scenarios were presented to the participants to gauge their ethical positions under certain circumstances. In only one of the five was there any statistically significant difference in the respondents’ propensity to agree with the ethically questionable position. The scenario concerned a willingness to pursue a profitable venture that would knowingly result in increased pollution. The Chinese and American participants were less willing to engage in the polluting behavior than the Jamaicans. The researchers posit that Jamaica is more apt to tolerate violations of pollution regulations due to “its concern for rebuilding its economy.” (Fok, et al. Page 25) The pressures of a burgeoning economy are much higher for Jamaica than for the post-industrial Chinese and U.S. economies and may affect the rationalization to elevate progress over environmental protections.
Concepts of positive and normative economics can be found in the study conducted by Fok and her colleagues.…...

Similar Documents

China Jamaica and America

...China, Jamaica, and America Ethics Case Study Tammy M Langewisch Eth/557 December 3, 2012 Andrew Sargent, MBA, JD China, Jamaica, and America Ethics Case Study In the article, “A Study of Differences in Business Ethical Values in Mainland China, the U. S. and Jamaica,” writes about the results of a second research performed that compares what has been considered third world countries, Mainland China and Jamaica, to the United States (U. S.), and how each countries culture impacts ethical decision making in businesses. The study contained five vignettes and two hypotheses. The vignettes were scenarios in which the subjects responded to, according to what they believed were ethical or those that were not. This paper will cover the culture that impacts China and Jamaica, the results of the research and ethics plays a role in decision making for financial, environmental, and cultural issues; how the concepts of positive and normative economics are reflected; and how market efficiency, economizing, and the market system affects these ethical issues in each country compared to the U. S. Ethics in Financial, Environmental, and Cultural Issues Mainland China was a socialist-based economy that converted to free market over 25 years ago. China’s culture is founded upon Confucian and Maoist, rather than capitalist, which impacts ethical decisions made by Chinese business leaders (Fok, Hartman, & Kwong, 2005). Jamaica’s heritage is capitalist and it is a low......

Words: 796 - Pages: 4

Ethical Issues That Wal-Mart Faced in India and China..Docx Uploaded Successfully

...Ethical Issues that Wal-Mart faced in India and China. Wal-Mart’s ethical business management is related to the global environment, which consists of financial markets, cultures, technologies and government policies. The market also consists of hyper competition from different countries such as China and India and regional players in the global environment. China has low cost offshore labor in the “flat world”, so that Chinese imports are so inexpensive to enter in U.S. So many factors lead most US manufactories to close the doors and eventually jobs are lost accelerate. The United States’ economic outlooks vary with regard to the global economy. In my opinion, the labor force is one of technologies in a developing country and it supports the globalization process. China as a global manufacturer and U.S. partner is a great source of world-class offshore technology services. Wal-Mart has its own external and internal stakeholders. WAL-MART Ethically wrongs its Employees * Wal-Mart executives have failed to pay workers overtime and admitted to being trained and told by their superiors to do so. One of the Wal-Mart mgr claimed that he/she has seen every Wal-Mart mgr change the hours other than the General Mgr. the 31 state lawsuits, and $50 MM class action payment in CO convincingly indicate that Wal-Mart violated the law, and in TX it was estimated that Wal-Mart cheated workers out of $150 MM. Another figure cited is that they underpaid 87,000 workers in the US by $34 MM......

Words: 1041 - Pages: 5

Ethical Issues

...Chapter One Strategy and Competition Chapter Overview Purpose The purpose of this chapter is to introduce the student to a variety of strategic issues that arise in the manufacturing function of the firm. Key Points 1. Manufacturing matters. This writer contends that the loss of the manufacturing base in the U.S. economy is not healthy and will eventually lead to an overall loss in the standard of living and quality of life in this country. It counters the argument that our evolution into a service economy is a natural and healthy thing. 2. Strategic dimensions. Along with cost and/or product differentiation, other dimensions along which firms distinguish themselves include (a) quality, (b) delivery speed, (c) delivery reliability, and (d) flexibility. 3. Classical view. The classical literature on manufacturing strategy indicates that strategy should be viewed in relation to one or more of the following issues: (a) time horizon, (b) focus, (c) evaluation, and (d) consistency. 4. Global competition. How do we measure our success and economic health on a global scale? One way is to examine classical measures of relative economic strength, which include (a) balance of trade, (b) share of world exports, (c) creation of jobs, and (d) cost of labor. However, such macro measures do not adequately explain why certain countries dominate certain industries. National competitive advantage is a consequence of several factors (factor conditions, demand conditions, related and......

Words: 25276 - Pages: 102

Ethical Issues

...Ethical Issues Ethics: The Hallmark of Leaders at All Levels Abstract The intent of the paper is educating people about the abuse of power. Why a code of conduct is necessary for a company to be successful. Examples of what can go wrong in certain situations when bad moral judgment is used for personal gain. How to correct violations with a new code of ethics and compliance officer to ensure these the code of ethics will be followed. 1. Table of Contents 1. Intro into a problem in the workplace page 4 2. A code of conduct page 5-6 3. Professional conduct page 7 4. Code of conduct in the workplace 5. Where to and how to implement the code of conduct page 7 6. The conclusion and solutions for unethical and moral character page 7 7. How the code of ethics you developed can be applied to deal with page 8 Your chosen ethical issue 8. How the character, values, and integrity of a leader can aid in Making your proposed code of ethics more than just another document that employees acknowledge when they are hired, but instead make it a valued part of their everyday work lives for your fictional business page 9 Ethical Issues Identify and clearly describe an ethical issue. The ethical issue I will discuss is bribery in the work place; an inspector took a bribe to allow a property owner to break city code while building a......

Words: 2020 - Pages: 9

Economy China

...ESCOLA SUPERIOR DE PROPAGANDA E MARKETING PROJETO DE GRADUAÇÃO INTERNACIONAL MONOGRAFIA JEAN-PIERRE DE AZEVEDO LUIZ LUÍS RAMÓN SIERRA FILHO MATHEUS TALLAVASSO VASSOVINIO ECONOMIA VOLTADA PARA A EXPORTAÇÃO: vantagens e desvantagens para a China São Paulo 2013/1 JEAN-PIERRE DE AZEVEDO LUIZ LUÍS RAMÓN SIERRA FILHO MATHEUS TALLAVASSO VASSOVINIO ECONOMIA VOLTADA PARA A EXPORTAÇÃO: vantagens e desvantagens para a China Trabalho apresentado como requisito parcial para avaliação da disciplina Métodos e Técnicas de Pesquisa no quinto semestre do curso de Graduação em Relações Internacionais com ênfase em Marketing e Negócios da Escola Superior de Propaganda e Marketing – ESPM. Prof. Felícia Alejandrina Urbina Ponce São Paulo 2013/1 SUMÁRIO 1 1.1 1.2 1.3 2 2.1 2.2 2.3 2.3.1 2.3.2 2.3.3 INTRODUÇÃO ............................................................................................................... 3 CONTEXTUALIZAÇÃO DO TEMA ........................................................................... 3 DEFINIÇÃO DE PROBLEMA, OBJETIVOS GERAL E ESPECÍFICOS .................. 4 JUSTIFICATIVA ........................................................................................................... 5 METODOLOGIA ........................................................................................................... 7 ABORDAGEM .............................................................................................................. 7......

Words: 4647 - Pages: 19

Three Business Problems, Situations, or Opportunities That Are Ethical Issues

...Ethical issue, as stated by Ferrell et al (2008) is “simply a situation, a problem, or even an opportunity that requires thought, discussion, or investigation to make a decision” (p. 60) whether it is right or wrong, ethical or unethical. Ethical issues results from the conflicts among individuals’ personal moral philosophies and values, the values and culture of their organizations and their society. Especially in the business environment, the ethical conflicts appear more normal when the benefit of one organization is the loss or suffering of the others. Ethical issues include many problems, situations or opportunities, however, within this context, I would like to discuss on the following three issues. First ethical issue relates to the environmental protection that becomes the most concerned today, especially in countries with high speed of industrialization and urbanization like Vietnam. Pollution is caused from dust, raw sewage, toxic chemicals, fertilizers and pesticides, industrial waste… from factories and transportation vehicles that are damaging the living environment. In a latest report by the United Nations Environmental Program (UNEP), Vietnam stands 6th among the cities having highest level of pollution when dust is as 2 to 3 times higher than normal level. Some rivers in Vietnam are now being called as “black rivers” instead of their own names as the water is being so polluted with bad smell that no fish can exist after years they are being filtered by waste...

Words: 844 - Pages: 4

Ethical Issues in a Global Economy

...Ethical Issues in the Global Economy The business world is changing. It is evolving into a fully integrated global economy, where corporations and their managers are faced with moral dilemmas and ethical questions as they expand their operations on a worldwide scale. As raw material sources, supply chains, and production facilities are increasingly being built and moved overseas, businesses are beginning to uncover new issues which complicate their processes and operations. Gray areas are developing relating to humanitarian and labor issues, environmental concerns, and governmental regulations that challenge even the most socially responsible and forward thinking companies. At the same time, citizens and shareholders alike are challenging global firms to address the Triple Bottom Line approach, an approach that equally emphasizes the importance of people, the planet, and profits in measuring the success of any given firm. Companies are still expected to succeed financially, while simultaneously taking care of the environment, their employees, and the communities in which they operate. In order to gain insight into this situation, one may consider The Travels Of A T-Shirt In The Global Economy by Pietra Rivoli. In this case study of a truly global product, Rivoli explores the path that a simple cotton t-shirt follows from raw material, to finished product, and finally on to its own secondary market. She explores the people behind each step in the process, the......

Words: 2900 - Pages: 12

Economy of China

...FEBRUARY 2010 Policy Brief ORGANISATION FOR ECONOMIC CO-OPERATION AND DEVELOPMENT Economic Survey of China, 2010 What are the key challenges facing the economy? How should the monetary policy framework evolve? What reforms are needed in financial and product markets? How should social safety nets be strengthened? How has the labour market evolved? Can pensions be enhanced? How should health care be improved? For further information For further reading Where to contact us? Summary Since the OECD’s first Economic Survey of China in 2005, China has continued to expand rapidly. The economy is also weathering the global crisis remarkably well, not least thanks to prompt and vigorous macroeconomic policy action. Economic expansion is projected to continue over the medium run, and China’s share in the world economy is set to grow further. Despite the recent decline in the current account surplus, some imbalances remain, notably an overly high national saving rate, but ongoing reforms can be expected to help alleviate them over time. Structural reform has continued on a broad front in recent years, with an increasing focus on the need for social cohesion. Even so, efforts are under way or still needed in a number of areas to sustain improvements in living standards over the longer run. Further upgrading the monetary policy framework. China’s monetary policy framework has gradually become more market-based, with money growth as the main intermediate target. Going forward,......

Words: 5342 - Pages: 22

Issues in Jamaica

...KINGSTON The chapter starts off by telling us about how Christopher Columbus arrived in the island of Jamaica in 1494. The population then of was a handful and the population was cleansed and was dominated by English colonial officials and plantation owners as well as enslaved Africans and indentured Indians. v The main economic resource of the island was from sugar cane and this was done through captive labour. ( the labour from slaves) v Rebellions came over time and this generated a strong revulsion for colonial rule and because of this, it took centuries for independence to finally come to Jamaica. It finally came in 1962 v With the introduction of independence, slavery became abolished and moved the history of Jamaica forward. With the introduction of independence, there was a new regime led by Nelson Manley. The political party he belonged to crafted a social development agenda to respond to the bondage of post colonial life. v In the course of pursing the new policy of independence, the government was permitted to channel industrial investment into those areas of the economy that needs social development. The government relied on direct foreign investment. This involvement with foreign actors earned Jamaica with most of its foreign exchange earnings. With this, Jamaica became the largest exporter of mineral to North America and Canada. Even as they were exporters, Jamaicans didn’t benefit from their natural resources. The only way they......

Words: 712 - Pages: 3

Google China Ethical Issues

...Google China – Ethical Issues The Business Environment March 07, 2011   Table of Contents Preface 3 Google 4 Background 4 Google’s Philosophy 4 Google China 5 Ethical Issues 6 Conclusion 9 Annexure 10 References 10 Chinese Business Culture 10 The Great Firewall of China 11 Events Timeline 12   Preface This paper focuses on the Ethical issues pertaining to Google’s position in China around 2006. Google has been criticized for supporting the Chinese government censor policy and aiding them by restricting the anti-government information within China. Google in its quest to gain market share entered the Chinese market adhering to the Chinese government censorship policies. Google’s approach at that point in time was certainly against its corporate values and mission, hence unethical. However events of 2010 have forced Google to revisit its position and are resulted in redirecting its search engine traffic to Hong Kong. The paper provides a brief background to the Google, Chinese business culture, censorship policies in China and Google’s approach to enter the Chinese market. Later sections of the paper look at the ethical and unethical practices of Google in line with its corporate value, mission and strategies.   Google Background Since its inception in 1996, Google has grown by leaps and bounds. From offering search in a single language it now offer dozens of products and services in many different languages. Starting from two computer......

Words: 2493 - Pages: 10

Rise of China Economy

...THE RISE OF CHINA’S ECONOMY By Thomas G. Rawski Thomas G. Rawski, Professor of Economics and History, joined the University of Pittsburgh's faculty in 1985 after fourteen years at the University of Toronto. His research focuses on the nature and implications of recent developments and long-term changes in the economy of China. He delivered this paper at A History Institute for Teachers, March 19–20, 2011 on “China and India: Ancient Civilizations, Rising Powers, Giant Societies, and Contrasting Models of Development,” held at the University of Pennsylvania. This History Institute was co-sponsored by The Foreign Policy Research Institute’s Wachman Center as well as by three centers at the University of Pennsylvania – Center for East Asian Studies, South Asia Center, and Penn Lauder CIBER (Center for International Business Education and Research). 1 China’s remarkable economic boom, now in its fourth decade, has spawned numerous discussions of “China’s Rise.”2 Beijing’s self-congratulatory slogan “China’s peaceful rise” has advanced this theme. From a historical perspective, however, this terminology seems misplaced. Both the Ming (1368-1644) and Qing (1644-1912) empires occupied key positions in Asian trade and diplomacy. Crude figures compiled by Angus Maddison, author of several sweeping studies of global economic history, show China contributing nearly one-third of global output as late as 1820. The great boom of the late twentieth century has enabled China to regain some......

Words: 4916 - Pages: 20

Walmart China Issues

...Suggestions Walmart needs to adjust to the Chinese market, while leveraging its source of competitive advantage. This requires a delicate balance. At the US, the brand Walmart is associated with low price rather than quality. In China, where everyone is going for low prices and providing low quality to do so, Walmart’s own brand could be an assurance for low prices but with quality by making the Walmart name about more than just retailing. The suggested strategy in the 2008 Walmart supplier meetings shows that it’s heading in that direction (Business Week). This also follows Gome’s strategy of renaming its suppliers to their own brand (Business Week), but goes beyond it as the foreign brand in China is already associated with higher reliability and quality assurance. This actually holds true in China were retailers do a better job of enforcing supplier quality than the local regulations. With that, Walmart is still able to use its expertise and knowledge in supplier negotiation and distribution system to keep costs down. Although Walmart is a Joint-Venture, the sources do not mention any attempt to leverage the local partner to meet the local market, which seems the opposite to some other joint ventures discussed like Danone and Wahaha. Working together with the local partner to understand where and how the local regulations can be used or adjusted for Walmart’s success and gaining a stronger hold of the potential customer’s heart might help Walmart’s growth and dominance......

Words: 5066 - Pages: 21

Ethical Issues

...●● learning OBJECTIVES After studying Chapter 3, you will be able to: LO1 LO2 Explain how companies influence their ethics environment. LO3 Outline a process for making ethical decisions. LO4 Summarize the important issues surrounding corporate social responsibility. LO5 Discuss reasons for businesses’ growing interest in the natural environment. LO6 bat37233_ch03_050-071.indd 51 Describe how different ethical perspectives guide decision making. Identify actions managers can take to manage with the environment in mind. 11/11/09 11:01:16 AM Confirming Pages ● ETHICS The system of rules that governs the ordering of values. This chapter addresses the values and manner of doing business adopted by managers as they carry out their corporate and business strategies. In particular, we will explore ways of applying ethics, the system of rules that governs the ordering of values. We do so based on the premise that managers, their organizations, and their communities thrive over the long term when the managers apply ethical standards that direct them to act with integrity. In addition, we consider the idea that organizations may have a responsibility to meet social obligations beyond earning profits within legal and ethical constraints. As you study this chapter, consider what kind of manager you want to be. What reputation do you hope to have? How would you like others to describe your behavior as a......

Words: 15103 - Pages: 61

Chinas Economy

... Name: Lecturer: Course: Date: | | CHINESE ECONOMY Chinese economy can be described as a social market economy. A social market economy is whereby a social and economic system combines free market capitalism which supports private enterprise alongside social policies which establish both fair competition within the market and state (Das and Dilip, 25). Chinese social market economy was brought by reforms initiated by Deng Xiaoping. A social market economy has been advantageous in that there has been increased output of goods due to increased competition between firms. Low costs of production attract foreign investments as well as innovative ideas are encouraged as people look to ways of improving their goods and services and further reduction of costs of doing business. Disadvantages have also come about such as exploitation of workers, misplaced priorities as profit is put above the welfare of the people. Despite this disadvantages, Chinese economy has averaged a 10% increase in gross domestic product for the last 30 years reaching an all-time high of 105% in 1995 and a record low of 3.80% in the fourth quarter of 1990(Lin and Justin Yifu, pp: 5).This year the Chinese economy has had an annual growth of 6.9% making it the slowest growth since 2009 due to low property investment, dip in exports, low industrial output among others (Adler and Solomon, 5). Chinese decline in economic growth has been largely due to low output in state owned enterprises, accumulation of loans...

Words: 702 - Pages: 3

Ethical Issues

...Ethical Issues Ethical Issues in Corporate America Larry Goodman Business 610/ Organizational Behavior Prakash Menon April 10, 2011 Ethical Issues 1 The purpose of this paper is to look at the Ethical Issues in Corporate America. This paper will address areas regarding why ethical issues are a major concern in organizations, what influences impact ethical behavior and how organizations can influence ethical behavior in employees. To complete this task outside resources, such as books and articles will be utilized. According to Wise, Ethic is defined as, “the behavior that a business adheres to in its daily dealings with the world”. Ethic takes on many different forms with any organization, how ethics impacts employees is very important to the success and failure of the company. Organizations are more likely to achieve ethical success with the employees if the employees are properly trained to complete any desired task. Given the fact that the employees are not trained properly, makes them more likely to make a mistake or incapable of performing job duties, this is a condition that will influence the ethical behavior of the employee. Properly continued training will enable the employees an opportunity achieve better results and it will help the organization produce better products. The employer may utilize other areas to help drive desired ethical behavior. The employer may take steps to help increase the desired ethical behavior. The employer may use...

Words: 660 - Pages: 3

Descargar Office Professional ..ISO | Frosted Window Tint Etch Privacy Film Frost Self Adhesive Sticky Back Plastic | Haywire 2011 R5 XviD READNFO CaM-Blackjesus