Freire and Loewen Comparrisons

In: English and Literature

Submitted By terryj6855
Words 2044
Pages 9
“The Banking Concept of Education”

“The Banking Concept of Education,” from Pedagogy of the Oppressed by Paulo Freire. New York: Continuum, 1993. Translated by Myra Bergman Ramos [This is the citation information you will need to construct a Works Cited entry; for in-text citation, use Paulo Freire’s last name and the paragraph number (since this is a reprint and not the original, book-length source). Consult your Easy Writer for information about citing a book with a translator].

A careful analysis of the teacher-student relationship at any level, inside or outside the school, reveals its fundamentally narrative character. This relationship involves a narrating Subject (the teacher) and patient, listening objects (the students). The contents, whether values or empirical dimensions of reality, tend in the process of being narrated to become lifeless and petrified. Education is suffering from narration sickness.

The teacher talks about reality as if it were motionless, static, compartmentalized, and predictable. Or else he expounds on a topic completely alien to the existential experience of the students. His task is to "fill" the students with the contents of his narration—contents which are detached from reality, disconnected from the totality that engendered them and could give them significance. Words are emptied of their concreteness and become a hollow, alienated, and alienating verbosity.

The outstanding characteristic of this narrative education, then, is the sonority of words, not their transforming power. "Four times four is sixteen; the capital of Pará is Belim." The student records, memorizes, and repeats these phrases without perceiving what four times four really means, or realizing the true significance of "capital" in the affirmation "the capital of Pará is Belim," that is, what Belim means for Pará and what Pará means for Brazil.…...

Similar Documents

Hot and Cold Weather Comparrison Essey

...Comparison and Contrast Essay Hot and Cold Weather Comparisons Albert Weyant COMM/215 - Essentials of College Writing September 15, 2012 Dr. Nancy Reynolds Hot and Cold Weather Hot and cold climates will be discussed and the different comparisons between them. I will state my opinions and objectives pertaining to the two climates. The differences I will discuss are the climates, activities, and locations. Millions of people prefer to use the two different climates to accommodate themselves when the climates are in a comfortable temperature for them. Each year many lives are lost because of heat stroke and flu. The numbers are not very close. Four times as many people die from flu than heat stroke related deaths. Some prefer hot over cold and some, cold over hot. The differences between hot and cold are extreme. People have their own reasoning for the preferences. The first difference between Hot and Cold Weather are the climates The American Heritages, “the long-term prevalent weather conditions of an area, determined by latitude, position relative to oceans or continents, altitude, etc.,” describe climate. (2005). Climate, described by Merriam-Webster, is, “the non-specialist, climate means expected or habitual weather at a particular place and time of year. To the......

Words: 838 - Pages: 4

Paulo Freire and William Brickman

...Paulo Freire and William Brickman Born in Brazil in 1921, Paulo Freire was the son of an affluent family. When Wall Street crashed in 1929, they were compelled to move to the countryside where Paulo witnessed the impact poverty had on education (Flanagan, 2005). Freire perceived how education can be manipulated by an oppressor to keep the oppressed retrained with mind control (Flanagan, 2005). The oppressed, thorough education, would be able to see the circumstances that is their reality but understand that their situation is not natural and look for other possibilities. (Flanagan, 2005) “Education empowers the oppressed to discover alternatives to situations which have been taken as natural, necessary, and unchangeable” (Flanagan, 2005, p.186). In this approach, students are docile and educators have all the knowledge (Flanagan, 2005). Freire was also responsible for the banking concept of education and the student-teacher dialogue. The banking concept, according to Freire, is where students are passive learners and teachers provide the students with genuine and true information (Flanagan, 2005). “The teachers function is to fill students with contents of their narration: the teacher speaks, the students listen” (Flanagan, 2005, p.186). Only the teacher takes an active role in thinking, talking, etc., while the participation by the student is uninvolved. According to Freire, the student-teacher dialogue is a process by which students learn by praxis. They......

Words: 738 - Pages: 3

Paulo Freire

...1. How would you paraphrase Freire's central argument, his thesis? What key moments, key words, and key phrases in the essay clarify his thesis for you? Make sure to mention specifics from the texts. The central argument that Freire is trying to make is that the educational system is flawed. Teachers are simply putting information into containers (students) and the containers accept. “The student records, memorizes, and repeats…without perceiving” (1) what they are saying. There is no reciprocal learning happening, that you are told information and you regurgitate it back to prove your knowledge and understanding. “The teacher teaches and the students are taught.” (2) “The more completely he fills the receptacles, the better a teacher he is. The more meekly the receptacles permit themselves to be filled, the better students they are.” (1) He considers this to be the “banking concept of education. In which the scope of action allowed to the students extends only as far as receiving, filing, and storing the deposits”, which he also deems as incorrect, that there are indeed other ways to educate that produce better people. Freire goes on to argue that the banking concept should be left in the past and teachers should instead use a problem-posing concept. He believes that students must be able to see that what they learn can have an effect on the world thus have the ability to change the world. That, “sooner or later......

Words: 824 - Pages: 4

Caso Loewen

...O[{o0L66^> -SS (- ^¿/-(ji é HARVARD BUSINESS S C H O O L Xo\\3i*L ^ 9-201-082 REV: MARCH 4, 2002 The Loewen Group, Inc. (Abridged) In March 1999, John Lacey and the management team at the Loewen Group, Inc., had to decide what course of action to take in light of the company's imminent financial difñculties. On January 22,1999, Lacey, a renowned turnaround specialist, was appointed chairman of Loewen, the second largest death care company in North America. Headquartered in Burnaby, British Columbia, Loewen owned over 1,100 funeral homes and more than 400 cemeteries in the U.S. and Canadá; it also owned 32 funeral homes in the United Kingdom. The company had come a long way since its modest beginnings in Canadá, where Ray Loewen, the founder (and, until recently, chairman and CEO), started out helpinghis father run the family funeral business in the late 1950s. During the last two decades, Loewen Group had grown explosively, mainly by acquiring small independent funeral homes and cemeteries in densely populated urban markets; in recent years the company had also acquired several large established funeral chains. Over the last five years alone, Consolidated revenues had grown by nearly 30 percent a year, on average, from $303 million to over $1.1 billion. Despite its impressive growth, the company faced a major financial crisis. It lost $599 million for 1998, compared to earning $43 million the previous year. Loewen's on-going......

Words: 3933 - Pages: 16

Comparison of William Brickman and Paulo Freire

...A Comparison of William Brickman and Paulo Freire (1921-1997) Paulo Freire (1921-1997) was an advocate for the liberation of the oppressed through the process of critical thought. He learned at an early age that conventional education is a vehicle for oppression and to escape that oppression, one must develop critical consciousness. Freire believed that students should be “given encouragement and opportunity to engage in critical thinking in the quest for the humanization of both learner and teacher” (Flanagan, 2005, p. 189). This quest for humanization and the transcendence from oppression is attained when both teacher and student is neither subject nor object but equal in the process of exchanging learning. Freire’s methodology endures today in quality education at all levels as student creativity is both encouraged and enhanced through dialogue and lived experiences. William Brickman is known as the founder of the Comparative Education Society. His greatest contribution to the field of education was his extensive research in diversified education. Through his participation in various cultures and exchanges with foreign scholars, William Brickman led the charge for comparative education. He promoted his belief of academic freedom and championed the idea that “there was no one correct way of doing comparative education” (Brehm, W.C., and Silova, I., Summer 2010, p. 23). As with any pioneer, both Freire and Brickman struggled with resistance to their methodologies...

Words: 746 - Pages: 3

William Brickman and Paul Freire

...Compare and contrast William Brickman and Paul Freire By: Helena Gray Northcentral University Presented to Dr. Stein June 29, 2014 Introduction: This paper speaks about the two individuals, William Brickman and Paulo Frere’s. Even though some of their thought and view on education were different, they had some similarities. The paper will explain their birth, death, achievements and the difficulties both men faced through their journey in the field of education. Compare & Contrast William Brickman and Paulo Freire William Brickman was born on June 30, 1913 and died of Leukemia on June 22, 1988 at Philadelphia hospital. He was the founder and president of the comparative and International Education Society. Brickman attended city schools and earned his bachelor and master at the City College in New York, and his Ph.D at the University of Pennsylvania. His teaching began at City College, where he taught for over 40 years, the New York University and the University of Pennsylvania. One of his achievements as a teacher, and researcher, was in the field of education and Comparative and International Education. Brickman encouraged and published young scholars, contributed article to encyclopedia, and wrote many articles and reviews for professional journals. The opportunity to interact with people from other cultures at an early age drove him to learn their languages and pursue more into his research of comparative education (Silova & Brehm, 2010 p. 20). He......

Words: 680 - Pages: 3

Knowledge Is Power

...of activism that it does not apply to today’s public education system in America. I disagree. His analysis applies as much today as it did forty years ago, but the reason most do not recognize it is because it works so well. The educational system uses a concept that Freire details in his work, namely the banking concept of education. This method of teaching is “dehumanizing” in that it reduces students to “receptacles” whose only purpose in life is to be filled with information which is chosen by oppressors to be significant (Freire par. 4). Freire paints a picture of lifeless, mechanical, students, filing information into their brains without question or analysis; the very thing that he claims makes us human (par. 4,5). He asserts that this concept of education is oppressive by design. Indeed, it serves the oppressors’ goals in that “the more the oppressed can be led to adapt to (an environment where they question nothing), the more easily they can be dominated” (Freire par. 9). The control over educational subject matter plays a key role in oppression. Loewen's work Lies My Teacher Told Me: Everything Your American History Textbook Got Wrong details this role. Although I agree with the ideas of Freire and Loewen, that public education is used as a means to dominate and oppress the masses, it is important to note that we have the power to overcome this ploy with parental involvement in our children's education. Because subjects such as mathematics and science can be......

Words: 906 - Pages: 4

Analog Comparrison

...Analog and Digital Comparison Paper Team A NTC/362 Dr. Jose Gotay November 11, 2014 An analog signal is a moving nonstop amplitude and frequency line. A good example of an analog signal is when a person is talking on a cell phone, when the person speaks into the microphone on the cell phone the pressure from the mouth is stored in the phone and creates a current. The rise and fall of the current is the analog voice pattern signal. The digital signal is less complex than the analog signal; because the digital signal uses binary code or zero and one bits to transmit signals. Analog transmissions can be converted into digital transmissions and vice versa. Conversions are made possible by codecs and modems. Codecs combine analog-to-digital conversion and digital-to-analog conversion. Some codecs are able to reduce the amount of bits per second that are required for voice to be transmitted digitally. Compression is required when converting cell phone networks and video communications because of the limited spectrum and channels (Goleniewski & Jarret, 2007). A modem controls analog signals to encode digital data and demodulates the signal to decode the information sent. An analog signal works with computers to transform the digital data into electrical signals through a telephone channel and then demodulate the signals back into digital data. However, conversions have been known to cause malfunctions in the network so it is best......

Words: 544 - Pages: 3

Freire Essay

...conformity. This is being done by taking away any potential interactions between teachers and students, turning a bidirectional conversation into a one directional narrative where the teacher is raised to a position of knowledge, while the student is lowered to a position of ignorance. Freire explains this clearly by writing: In the banking concept of education, knowledge is a gift bestowed by those who consider themselves knowledgeable upon those whom they consider to know nothing. Projecting an absolute ignorance onto others, a characteristic of the ideology of oppression, negates education and knowledge as processes of inquiry. The teacher presents himself to his students as their necessary opposite; by considering their ignorance absolute, he justifies his own existence (para. 6). In order to go over the obstacle brought upon by the banking concept of education, one does not negate the existence of the roles of teacher and student, rather it is required that the progressive teacher use their organizational role to encourage students to challenge and criticize taking part in the creation of knowledge, and developing a mutual relationship of understanding and social transformation. Freire insists on this solution by stating that “The raison d’être of libertarian education, on the other hand, lies in its drive towards reconciliation. Education must begin with the solution of the teacher-student contradiction, by reconciling the poles of the contradiction so that both are......

Words: 623 - Pages: 3


...information to students and not taking the time to communicate with the students. (4) By using a banking method to learning, they are taking the real meaning of what they are teaching out of the equation. (3) Some of the key words and phrases that clarify the thesis for me started with the mention of narration. (4) This concept points out the fact that teachers are just teaching in a way that students are meant to memorize the subject not really know the true meaning behind it. The next point was when Freire brought the concept of oppression. (11) This is where the paper turned into more than just a student teacher relationship, but rather into a broader oppressor and oppressed relationship. The last point was when Freire was describing man as just being a spectator, not a re-creator. (para 17) Those were some of the key points that stood out to me and clarified his thesis. 4. At the end of Freire's essay, he discusses the importance of "communication." Explain. I think what Freire is trying to point out about communication is that if teachers don't teach the real meanings; they will never really be able to authenticate the student's thinking. (para 22) Also, he said early in the passage that communication is key because the teacher isn't the only one teaching; the student is teaching the teacher as well....

Words: 364 - Pages: 2


...Concept of Education,” Paulo Freire relates his personal experiences of oppression in his native country. The Brazilian educator devoted his life of adult literacy. Loewen essay “Lies My Teacher Told Me,” argues the American history textbooks have the wrong facts. The sociologist feels the American students are lied to and misled in their history classes. Freire and Loewen essays both are informative account of a failed education system. Although scholars capitalized education, they failed to apply the importance in one education system. Freire argues there are two types of conceptual tools; Banking concept of education and problem posting method. In the tradition type of education, however, the teacher stores the information the student listens. The goal of banking education was to immobilize the student within the existing structure conditioning them into memorize the materials (Freire.web). I felt the ability to overcome the fear of memorize the lesson. In a sense, we all are a result of banking the education. In my early days, in high school, I had some experience of understanding the lesson. Robinson 2 I can remember my history teacher given me an assignment to complete in class; of just what she went over. I struggled a bit, because Mrs. Hall was a fun teacher; she made lessons fun in class. In the reading, How Freire concept of......

Words: 843 - Pages: 4

Court Comparrison and Contrast Paper

...COURT COMPARISON AND CONTRAST PAPER 1 Court Comparison and Contrast Paper COURT COMPARISON AND CONTRAST PAPER 2 Comparing State and Federal Court Systems There are many factors that involve the differences in state and federal courts. The three major factors that separate the two court systems are the structure, the selection of judges, and the types of cases that are presented in each of the two court levels. There are many reasons that there are two different court levels. This is so that we have checks and balance between the federal courts and the state courts. The structure of the Federal courts is based off Article III of the constitution of the United States. This article gave the federal system the power to create the Supreme Court as well as all the lower federal courts. The federal court system is broken down into six different types of courts which starting from the highest are the Supreme Court, United States Court of Appeals, United States District Courts, as well as the special federal courts which are the United States Bankruptcy Courts and the United States Courts of Special Jurisdiction. Within each of these courts they each handle specific cases that are presented to them. The State Court System is broken down into four different levels of courts. First are the trial......

Words: 1458 - Pages: 6

Paulo Freire: ‘Banking’ Concept of Education

...Paulo Freire: ‘Banking’ Concept Of Education Paulo Freire is saying that the teacher-student relationship is poor because of the fact that the teacher is just narrating about the subject of which the students are just listening and are not really involved. Freire is knowledgeable on the subject that the teacher is narrating, but the students are having troubles understanding the narration because of the words that the teacher speak of being foreign to them. If the teacher would go more into detail about the subject and not just lecture about a portion of the subject but get the students involved, they would not feel so alienated on the subject. Students can’t learn much just by memorization and repeating what they see or hear such as, “four times four is sixteen; the capital of Para is Belem.” “The student records, memorizes, and repeats these phrases without perceiving what four times four really means, or realizing the true significance of “capital” in the affirmation “the capital of Para is Belem, “that is, what Belem means for Para and what Para means for Brazil.” In which I totally agree on because all through school I was a student that would just copy or say the subject without really learning what I was copying or saying. Students are similar to empty receptacles, and teachers knowledge is what goes into the receptacles the more the teacher teaches the students the more the empty receptacles ( the students ) will fill with the knowledge of the subject of......

Words: 345 - Pages: 2

Letter to Freire

...Former Teacher Future Community Organizer Rural Old South, GA 30000 August 23, 2011 Dear Paulo Freire, As a former teacher of students at a public therapeutic school, I feel that we have a connection, if only as fellow educators. Most teachers only want the best for their students. I am against the thought of “banking education” (pouring information into a student, and then the students spit the information back out) as I know you are. In my former school for “troubled children,” the teachers and other staff had power over the students. This was for safety concerns, such as suicide. I know that you are known for actively sharing power, and believe in power “with the people.”In your work with marginalized people you never blamed the victim, as is often done. I know that you are famous, but you also identify with common people and educators like me. Our school has had many issues primarily with our funding. But the main problem is (I realize that you like to name the problem first) that I and other former teachers are getting ready to lose our retirement benefits! We worked extra hours weekly at our local community elementary school to ensure that our benefits would be available when we retired! Now when many of us need more income, it is going to be reduced, or discontinued. This problem can easily be explained. The funds were redirected to a fleet of expensive cars that are being driven around by public school board members. Now that the problem has......

Words: 751 - Pages: 4

Loewen Case Study (Memo Format)

...Mr. Loewen – After some careful consideration and examination, I recommend that we accept SCI’s bid of $43 per share. My recommendation is based upon my assessment of four things: * Our position after the Mississippi case settlement * Our financial situation * Our business model * SWOT and Industry Analysis First, the Mississippi case has somewhat damaged our company’s image and may portray us as a company that does not honor legal agreements. Not only was a contract broken that brought the case originally, but so was the settlement as a number of the “subject to” provisions were not met. If this be the case, then it could stand to reason that we may be viewed as untrustworthy in other agreements. Being that acquisitions are based more so on the intangibles and our reputation as “the preferred acquirer” is key to our ability to attract high quality acquisitions this sullying of our image may hamper our efforts at quality growth. This case has also put us in a precarious financial situation. The settlement has necessitated that we undertake a refinancing of the company to cover the cash portion of the agreement. While we were able to ease investor nerves and regain some share price, after losing more than 50% of share value, that confidence is tentative and dependent upon us maintaining our acquisition pace and operational profitability. This will be a hard feat as our acquisitions costs growth rate has averaged 80% over the last three years and to...

Words: 686 - Pages: 3

Thám Tử Lừng Danh Conan chap 591 | Speed Kills | Antirughe