Program Keluarga Harapan Main Findings from the Impact Evaluation of Indonesia’s Pilot Household Conditional Cash Transfer Program

In: Social Issues

Submitted By jrjellema
Words 16126
Pages 65
Public Disclosure Authorized

Public Disclosure Authorized


Program Keluarga Harapan
Main Findings from the Impact Evaluation of Indonesia’s Pilot Household Conditional Cash Transfer Program

Public Disclosure Authorized

Public Disclosure Authorized

World Bank Office Jakarta June 2011

This report was prepared by the Poverty Team, part of the Poverty Reduction and Economic Management (PREM) group in the World Bank Office Jakarta. Vivi Alatas, the Task Team Leader, led the analytical activities and oversaw the preparation of the report. She was supported by a team that included: Nur Cahyadi, Elisabeth Yunita Ekasari, Sarah Harmoun, Budi Hidayat, Edgar Janz, Jon Jellema, Hendratno Tuhiman, and Matthew Wai-Poi. The University of Gadjah Mada (UGM), Center for Public Policy Studies, implemented the baseline and final survey. The analysis for this evaluation was based on survey data that was collected and processed by some 860 enumerators and researchers. The survey work was led and overseen by Susan Wong. This report also draws from the findings of the resulting 2007 baseline survey report written by Robert Sparrow, Jossy Moeis, Arie Damayanti and Yulia Herawati. The Center for Health Research at the University of Indonesia, with the support of partner universities across the country, prepared a report in 2010 on the implementation of Program Keluarga Harapan (PKH), based on qualitative and quantitative spot-checks of the program. In addition, SMERU, an independent research organization in Indonesia, provided complementary qualitative studies in 2007 and 2009. These excellent reports have contributed to efforts to better understand how PKH works and contribute to reform efforts. Their work complements the findings from this impact evaluation, providing inputs for policy makers responsible for oversight and expansion of the…...

Similar Documents

Program Planning and Evaluation Paper

...Program Planning and Evaluation Paper Many people believe that evaluation is about proving the success or failure of a program. This myth assumes that success is implementing the perfect program and never having to hear from employees, customers or clients again -- the program will now run itself perfectly. This doesn't happen in real life. Success is remaining open to continuing feedback and adjusting the program accordingly. Evaluation gives you this continuing feedback. When beginning an evaluation, program people will often want the answer to this question: ●Does the program work? And how can it be improved? However, there are many equally important questions ● Is the program worth while? ● Are there alternatives that would be better? ● Are there unintended consequences? ● Are the program goals appropriate and useful? An evaluation can help a program improve their services, but can also help ensure that the program is delivering the right services. An evaluation is a systematic assessment. Evaluations should follow a systematic and mutually agreed on plan. Plans will typically include the following: Determining the goal of the evaluation: What is the evaluation question, what is the evaluation to find out. How will the evaluation answer the question: What methods will be used? Making the results useful, how will the results be reported so that they can be used by the organization to make improvements? (Kumpfer and Milward, 1993) Program Planning and......

Words: 787 - Pages: 4

Program Planning and Evaluation

...Program Planning and Evaluation Paper Axia College Program Planning and Evaluation Paper The Santa Rosa Philharmonic Youth Symphony (SRPYS) is an organization which supports young people who love music, encourages quality musicianship, and advanced leadership skills through their program. Local elementary and middle schools have had to cut the music programs from their curriculum; parents, students, and community members are concerned that this lack of support from the education community will discourage talented individuals. SRPYS is an organization which has developed plans to educate and advance the skills of young musicians. Their program planning and evaluation techniques are established, but always open to change as the students and musical tastes vary from year to year. Program planning and evaluation are two different processes in any human services agency, but are related to each other in many ways. Program planning is a process through activities or interventions which address and facilitate changes in a specific problem or problems. (Terao & Yuen, 2003) Through this planning, new programs can be implemented which can more appropriately address the problem or add new aspects to an existing program. Program evaluation provides information about how well a program is meeting the needs of its clientele, staff, the community, and its mission. Ongoing assessments allow for changes which need to be made as participants change, needs change, or there are better......

Words: 986 - Pages: 4

Program Planning and Evaluation that I chose from Appendix B, is the PEACE domestic violence Agency. The mission for the PEACE domestic violence agency is to empower abuse Survivors, reduce the victim’s trauma, as well as promote recovery through their programs Direct services. In order to provide effectiveness for this agency, as well as succeed, Program planning should be used in correlation with the mission of the organization. There needs to be different components that the planning needs to provide, that includes Inputs, and the planning must also include a theory for its processes and for the Decisions of the program. Another component for this agency’s planning processes, is Program evaluations, to ensure that their services and delivery of services, are actually Providing correctly for their participants, and clients. By conducting consistent program Evaluations, the agency will be able to revise and improve their planning. I believe that finding out great information, is to ask a series of questions, the First question is asking how program planning and program evaluation describe, how the Two components of evaluation and planning are related. In my own opinion, I believe They are deeply related, because once you have a good plan in line, you have to Conduct an evaluation, to see if ......

Words: 753 - Pages: 4

Program Evaluation

...Program evaluation is a systematic method for collecting, analyzing, and using information to answer basic questions about a program. While there are many types of program evaluations, and many terms used to describe them, evaluations are typically divided into two major categories: process evaluations and outcome evaluations. Process evaluations assess whether an intervention or program model was implemented as planned, whether the intended target population was reached, and the major challenges and successful strategies associated with program implementation. Outcome evaluations determine whether, and to what extent, the expected changes in a public health or not-for- profit company’s outcomes occur and whether these changes can be attributed to the program or program activities. Five reason to conduct a program evaluation in the public health and not- for- profits sectors. #1 A program evaluation can find out what works and doesn’t work. A process or outcome evaluation enables program managers to answer basic questions about a program’s effectiveness, including: Are participants benefiting from the program services? Are strategic implementations working? Are employees satisfied with the changes, and so. #2 A program evaluation can showcase the effectiveness of a program to the community and funders. #3 A program evaluation can improve staff’s frontline practice with participants. #4 A program evaluation can increase a program’s capacity to conduct a......

Words: 457 - Pages: 2

Conditional Cash Transfers

...CONDITIONAL CASH TRANSFERS A World Bank Policy Research Report CONDITIONAL CASH TRANSFERS REDUCING PRESENT AND FUTURE POVERTY Ariel Fiszbein and Norbert Schady with Francisco H.G. Ferreira, Margaret Grosh, Nial Kelleher, Pedro Olinto, and Emmanuel Skoufias ©2009 The International Bank for Reconstruction and Development / The World Bank 1818 H Street NW Washington DC 20433 Telephone: 202-473-1000 Internet: E-mail: All rights reserved 1 2 3 4 5 12 11 10 09 This volume is a product of the staff of the International Bank for Reconstruction and Development / The World Bank. The findings, interpretations, and conclusions expressed in this volume do not necessarily reflect the views of the Executive Directors of The World Bank or the governments they represent. The World Bank does not guarantee the accuracy of the data included in this work. The boundaries, colors, denominations, and other information shown on any map in this work do not imply any judgement on the part of The World Bank concerning the legal status of any territory or the endorsement or acceptance of such boundaries. Rights and Permissions The material in this publication is copyrighted. Copying and/or transmitting portions or all of this work without permission may be a violation of applicable law. The International Bank for Reconstruction and Development / The World Bank encourages dissemination of its work and will normally grant permission to reproduce......

Words: 55566 - Pages: 223

Program Evaluation Overview

...Program Evaluation Overview 1 Program Evaluation Overview The unstable, unpredictable, and ever fluctuating economy makes a good atmosphere for organizations to reap the benefits of a program evaluation. Competitive success in the everchanging marketplace will only occur when an organization puts into place continuing program feedback and program adjustments or adaptations (McNamara, 2006). There are several program evaluation models and methods available to any organization, making the stakeholders the key decision makers of the identity of scope and type of evaluation that will lend itself toward the futures goals and vision of the organization. McDavid and Hawthorn (2006) explain that there is a need for any organization conducting a programs evaluation to generate specific material for planning, design, implementation, and assessment to obtain desired results and to solve any problems or issues. To develop an evaluation focusing on relevance, utility, and design that specifically matches the organization’s needs, the stakeholders must not only address the issues at hand. They also must select an individual or team, which is internal, external, or combination of both to makeup the goal-oriented a program evaluation team. What is a Program Evaluation Boulmetis and Dutwin (2005, p. 4) define a program evaluation as the systematic and structural process of data collection. With these an organization can discerne if and to what degree organizational goals are achieved...

Words: 2241 - Pages: 9

Audit Program for Cash

...Substantive Audit Program- Cash Balances Assertions: 1. The amount of cash is not materially more than the amount shown on the balance sheet. (checked with procedure 3, 5 and 7) 2. All cash has been recorded. (Checked with procedures 3, 5 and 7) 3. Cash is correctly shown as a current asset. (Checked with procedure 12) 4. Cash is not restricted to noncurrent use. (Checked with procedure 12) 5. All deposits and disbursements of cash reflect transactions before the end of the year. (Checked with procedure 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7) Procedures 1. All reconciliations are for valid bank accounts, obtain confirmation from a third party (Existence) 2. AOW vouched deposit in transit to the cutoff bank statement, noted it cleared the bank on january 4 2010, appears to be a valid reconciling items. (Existence) 3. AOW traced selected January deposits from the cutoff bank statement to the cash receipts journal. No other reconciling items. (Completeness) 4. AOW vouched outstanding check to cash disbursement journal and cutoff bank statements, noting the check cleared after 12/31. (Existence) 5. AOW made a selection from the cash disbursements journal and trace to the cutoff bank statement to test outstanding checks for completeness. No exceptions noted. (Completeness) 6) All outstanding checks from the cutoff statement written before year end are included on the reconciliation. (Existence) 7) All deposits from the cutoff statement made before year end are......

Words: 282 - Pages: 2

Program Evaluation

...The program I am going to talk about in this case report is the Prescription Drug Monitoring Program (PDMP) in the United States. A brief history about the Prescription Drug Monitoring Program, through 1989, nine Prescription Drug Monitoring Program has been established. Two were located in state Attorneys General offices (California 1939 and Pennsylvania, 1972); two departments of Public Safety (Hawaii, 1943 and Texas, 1981) one in Department of Substance Abuse Services (Illinois, 1961); one in a Board of Pharmacy; and one in a Department of Consumer Affairs, Bureau of Health Professions (Michigan, 1988). How PDMPs are organized and operated varies among states. Each state determines which agency houses the PDMP; which controlled substances must be reported; which types of dispensers are required to submit data (e.g., pharmacies); how often data are collected; who may access information in the PDMP database (e.g., prescribers, dispensers, or law enforcement); the circumstances under which the information may (or must) be accessed; and what enforcement mechanisms are in place for noncompliance. A lot of people die from overdose of drugs in the United States and from drug abuse, not only that but there a lot of non-medical drug use in the United States as well. According to the Congressional Research Service Seven million individuals aged 12 or older (2.7% of this population) were current nonmedical users of Prescription or psychotherapeutic drugs in 2010 over 1 million......

Words: 1612 - Pages: 7

Program Evaluation

...Program Planning and Evaluation Paper Kendra Hammond HSM/270 June 16, 2013 William Latta When creating a human services organization, program planning and program evaluation is vital. For a successful organization one can not exist without the other. Program planning entails researching, making goals, setting objectives, and answers who, what, and why questions. The development of program planning helps establish what resources will be needed to achieve the goals and objectives of the human services organization. The finances and budget are also included in program planning. In the program plan it should include what is the problem that is being addressed, why this problem exists, who is the target population, and where the target population is demographically sited. When creating a program plan, it requires logical thinking and a high level of information processing. The plan should be able to provide information on the services that the program wishes to provide to their clients. Throughout the thought process of the plan, the program should consider and include in the plan what obstacles they may encounter and ways to overcome them. The program planning stage in creating a human services organization is essential, because it determines the budget, the timeline, and sets expectations for the entire organization. The heart of this stage is how the organizations product and services will be developed and delivered. Program planning should be done thoroughly and......

Words: 727 - Pages: 3

Conditional Cash Transfer Program

...Chapter 22 Conditional Cash Transfer Programs: A “Magic Bullet” for Reducing Poverty? Michelle Adato and John Hoddinott I n 1997, the government of Mexico introduced a conditional cash transfer (CCT) program called Programa de Educación, Salud, y Alimentación (PROGRESA) to provide assistance to about 300,000 extremely poor households. The essential premise of a CCT program is a cash transfer to households conditioned on their participation in health, nutrition, and education services. Ten years later, PROGRESA, now Oportunidades, covers more than 5 million households in all 31 Mexican states. Approximately 20 countries have adopted a pilot or full-scale CCT program, and another 20 countries have expressed interest in starting one. Most current programs are in Latin America, but others can be found in Asia, Africa, and the Caribbean, and interest is increasing among African countries struggling with extreme poverty and low human capital. CCT programs are increasingly perceived as being “a magic bullet in development.” Are they? This chapter presents a review of the rationale for and operation of CCT programs, an assessment of their effectiveness, and a discussion of key issues facing countries considering these interventions or reforming existing programs. How Do CCT Programs Work? CCT programs have the following characteristics: they are targeted to poor households, and the cash transfers are usually paid to mothers. Some programs also include transfers such as......

Words: 3141 - Pages: 13

Conditional Cash Transfer

...Conditional Cash Transfer Programs in Developing Settings: Executive Summary Conditional Cash Transfer (CCT) programs provide cash payments to poor households that meet certain behavioral requirements, generally related to children’s health, nutrition and education.1 For example, in Mexico’s PROGRESA, grants are provided to poor families with children under 18 enrolled in primary and secondary school on condition that the parents send children to school and regularly visit health centers. Evaluation results show that in general CCTs are effective means of reducing poverty and incentivizing parents to invest in the health and education of their children.2 CCTs are versatile programs, and have been used in a variety of different countries and regions worldwide. The largest CCTs such as Brazil’s Bolsa Escola and Mexico’s PROGRESA cover millions of households aimed at developing human capital in education attendance and health services. In Honduras and Colombia, CCTs are focused more narrowly on extremely poor households to increase educational attainment and reduce child labor. In Cambodia, CCTs have been implemented to address gender disparities in education. Recent CCT pilot programs are being used in Sub-Saharan Africa to reduce the risk of HIV/AIDS infection. There are three important elements to consider when designing a CCT program: payment system, payment size and desired impact. The payment systems used in CCTs varies across countries. Most of the Latin American...

Words: 561 - Pages: 3

4ps-Pantawid Pamilyang Pilipino Program

...thresholds increased by 11.1 percent from the first semester of 2009 to the first half of the 2012 compared to the 26.0 percent increase between the first semesters of 2006-2009,(NSCB 2012). According to the report of National Statistical Board, poverty incidence among Filipino families estimated a rate of 22.3 percent during the first semester of 2012, and 23.4 percent and 22.9 percent during the same periods in 2006 and 2009. Statistical data showed that poverty in the Philippines increases each year and due to this problem, the government developed the Pantawid Pamilyang Pilipino Program (4P’S) that has now become its flagship social assistance program to help the poor. Pantawid Pamilyang Pilipino Program is a Modified Conditional Cash Transfer for the poor families in the Philippines. According to Lucy Basset in her discussion paper entitled “Can Conditional Cash Transfer Programs Play a Greater Role in Reducing Child Undernutrition?, October 2008, Conditional Cash Transfer Conditional Cash Transfer programs (CCTs) provide cash payments to poor households that meet certain behavioral requirements, generally related to children’s health care and education. These CCTs promotes human development in terms of different services such as in the field of education, health, nutrition and livelihood that serves as the vehicle in alleviating poverty and at the same time, to contribute significantly to the improving society. Conditional Cash Transfer program started during the......

Words: 3464 - Pages: 14

4p's Program

...BENEFICIARIES OF THE PANTAWID PAMILYANG PILIPINO PROGRAM OF BRGY. BALATAS, NAGA CITY”. (An Undergraduate Thesis in Partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of Bachelor of Arts in Development Communication. Adviser: Karlos Jerome N. Llorin, MDC The 4Ps is a human development program and the poverty reduction strategy of the national government that provides CCT grants to extremely poor families in order to improve their health, nutrition and education especially the children aged 0- 14. The said program has two objectives: 1) Social Assistance, which aims to grant cash assistance to the poor to address their immediate need; and 2) Social Development, which aims to break the intergenerational poverty cycle through investments in human capital. One of the conditions under the said program before the beneficiaries will receive their CCT is the Family Development Session (FDS). It aims to widen the knowledge and boost the skills of parents and help them to understand and meet the health and education conditions of the program. The FDS is being done by the 4P’s workers through home visits, the use of modules on modular sessions guide for parents, family drug prevention program, parent effectiveness service and empowerment and viii reaffirmation of paternal abilities. The role of the parents in helping their children attain their health and educational growth is very important, the mothers or the heads of households are required to attend the FDS at least once a......

Words: 5897 - Pages: 24

Program Planning and Evaluation

...Program Planning and Evaluation Paper The PEACE Domestic Violence Agency is an agency that serves the community of Portland. Oregon. This agency is one that thrives to break the cycle of both domestic and sexual abuse amongst men, women, and children. They are a nonprofit agency that depends on funding from two main sources, The Small Grants Program and The Investor Program. This agency depends on funding from outside sources in the form of grants, two to be precise. Now, because they use grants from these sources for financial assistance, they have to use program planning. Program planning is a multi-step process that generally begins with the definition of the problem and development of an evaluation plan. An evaluation plan is basically a part of a grant proposal that gives information to improve a project during development, in which funding is needed. Since this agency requires grants for funding, program evaluation is needed to collect and analyze information to answer questions about projects and policies about their effectiveness and efficiency. Program evaluation is a detailed assessment of the outcome of a program, against established measures or expected results to determine if it achieved its objectives. ("What is program evaluation? definition and meaning," n.d.) Both program planning and program evaluation are needed because they are both steps in the larger process of program development. Within this specific agency, program planning is defining the......

Words: 889 - Pages: 4

Program Planning and Evaluation

...Program Planning and Evaluation Santa Rosa Philharmonic Youth Symphony (SRPYS) is an organization that supports young individuals to expand and advance the skills as musicians. Many schools across the nation have to cut funding for music programs from their curriculum. Many parents, students, and community members are concerned that cutting music programs from the curriculum will discourage students from expanding or discovering their talent. SRPYS has developed plans to educate and advance the skills of young musicians. SRPYS has planning and evaluations techniques in place but are always open to need ideas for the students because musical tastes change with each new school year. Program planning and evaluation are related in many ways but are two different processes. Program planning is a process through activities or interventions which address and facilitate changes in a specific problem or problems (Terao & Yuen, 2003). Through planning new programs can come into existence. This helps organizations meet the needs of clients. Program planning helps change old programs my adding new aspects to meet the needs of clients. Program evaluation gives information on the organization, how well it is performing; see if the organization is meeting the needs of clients, the community, and the mission statement. Ongoing evaluations help allow the organization to make changes when needed. As a program is being developed assessments and evaluations are needed to be put into place...

Words: 828 - Pages: 4

Ver National Theatre Live: Coriolanus Pelicula Completa en Linea (2014) 9 | Sci Hard | MXGP PRO Update v20181023-CODEX